top of page
Untitled (A2 (Landscape))_Nero_AI_Image_Upscaler_Photo_Face.png

LE ROUX VIVIER ATTORNEYS

Behind the Contract: The Undisclosed Principal

Writer: lerouxvivierattorn
lerouxvivierattorn
Oct 26
7 min read

Updated: 2 days ago


Can a person enter into a contract in their own name while acting for someone else? Under certain circumstances, South African law recognises the doctrine of the undisclosed principal, which can affect who has rights and obligations under a contract.

 

When entering into a commercial agreement, it is natural to assume that the parties to the contract are the people or businesses expressly identified in it. However, the law of agency recognises circumstances in which a person contracts in their own name while acting on behalf of another person whose involvement is not disclosed to the other contracting party.

 

This raises an important question: if the true principal is not identified when the contract is concluded, can that principal later enforce the contract or be held liable under it?

 

What is an undisclosed principal?

 

An undisclosed principal is a person on whose behalf another person (referred to as an “agent”) enters into a contract in their own name, without revealing that they are acting as an agent.

 

In an ordinary agency arrangement, an agent acts as a representative of a principal. The agent concludes a contract on the principal's behalf, and the rights and obligations arising from that contract ordinarily belong to the principal rather than the agent.

 

The position is different where the principal is undisclosed. The agent does not present themselves as a representative of another person but contracts in their own name. The third party may therefore believe that they are dealing directly with the person who will acquire the contractual rights and obligations.

 

The doctrine of the undisclosed principal recognises that, in appropriate circumstances, the undisclosed principal may nevertheless acquire rights and incur obligations under the contract, despite not having been identified as a contracting party. Importantly, the agent may also remain personally liable under the contract, notwithstanding the existence of an undisclosed principal.


When does the Undisclosed Principal Doctrine apply?

 

The doctrine does not apply merely because a person secretly hopes to benefit from a contract or because someone else concludes an agreement on their behalf. Certain requirements must be established.

 

First, the agent must have been authorised or mandated to conclude the contract on behalf of the principal. There must be a sufficient basis for establishing that the agent was acting on the principal's behalf and with the necessary authority at the time the contract was concluded. The principal's mere knowledge of the transaction, or the fact that the principal stands to benefit from it, is not enough.

 

Second, the agent must contract in their own name without disclosing that they are acting in a representative capacity. The other contracting party must understand the agent to be contracting on their own account, rather than being told that they are acting as an agent for someone else. This is what distinguishes an undisclosed principal from an unnamed principal.

 

Whether the undisclosed principal doctrine applies must be determined with reference to the particular agreement and the circumstances in which it was concluded. The doctrine does not automatically give a person rights under, or impose obligations arising from, every contract entered into by another person.

 

A practical example

Thabo wishes to purchase specialised machinery for his business but prefers not to reveal his involvement in the transaction. He therefore authorises Naledi to negotiate with a supplier and purchase the machinery on his behalf. Naledi enters into the sale agreement in her own name without disclosing that she is acting for Thabo.


The supplier believes that Naledi is purchasing the machinery for herself, unaware that she is acting on behalf of Thabo.


If the requirements of the undisclosed principal doctrine are satisfied, Thabo may enforce the contract directly against the supplier, despite not having been identified as a contracting party when the agreement was concluded. Similarly, Thabo may incur obligations under the contract, while Naledi may remain personally liable.


This is a recognised exception to the general principle of privity of contract, which ordinarily provides that only parties to a contract may enforce rights arising from it. The doctrine allows an undisclosed principal to institute legal proceedings in their own name without first requiring the agent to cede the contractual rights to them.


For example, if the supplier fails to deliver the machinery, Thabo may institute proceedings against the supplier in his own name, provided he can establish that Naledi was authorised to contract on his behalf and that the requirements of the doctrine have been met. The supplier may, however, raise any applicable contractual defences arising from its dealings with Naledi.


This example illustrates why identifying the parties entitled to enforce a contract, or those responsible for its obligations, is not always as straightforward as examining the names appearing on the agreement.

 

How does an undisclosed principal differ from an unnamed principal?

 

The distinction between an undisclosed principal and an unnamed principal is particularly important.

 

Where a person acts for an unnamed principal, they openly indicate that they are acting in a representative capacity but do not identify the principal. The other contracting party knows that the agent is acting for someone else, even though that person's identity is not revealed.

 

With an undisclosed principal, the person contracts in their own name without disclosing that they are acting for another person at all.

 

The distinction concerns more than terminology. It affects how the parties' conduct and intentions are understood and how the applicable principles of agency operate.


Why does the doctrine matter?

The doctrine can have significant consequences for both the person who enters into the contract and the person whose interests they represent.

 

1. Contractual rights and obligations

An undisclosed principal may, where the doctrine applies, be entitled to enforce the contract in their own name or be held liable for obligations arising from it. The fact that the principal was not disclosed at the time of contracting does not necessarily prevent this outcome. Similarly, the agent may remain personally liable under the agreement, meaning that the third party may have remedies against both the agent and the undisclosed principal, subject to the applicable legal principles.

 

2. The position of the contracting party

A supplier, service provider or other contracting party may believe that they are dealing with one person, only to discover that another person claims rights or is alleged to bear obligations under the agreement. This can create uncertainty, particularly where the identity or financial position of the true principal would have influenced the decision to contract.

 

3. Disputes about the parties' intentions

The circumstances in which the agreement was concluded may become important. The court may need to consider whether the person was genuinely acting on behalf of a specific principal, whether the arrangement falls within the doctrine, and what the parties intended to achieve through their dealings.

 

The doctrine should therefore not be treated as an automatic means of adding another party to an existing contract. Its application depends on the relevant facts and legal requirements.


Does the doctrine apply to every contract?

No. The existence of an undisclosed principal does not automatically mean that the principal can enforce or be held liable under every agreement concluded by another person.

 

The nature of the transaction, the parties' intentions and the circumstances surrounding the conclusion of the contract must be considered. The doctrine must also be distinguished from other legal arrangements, including a person contracting for their own account while reserving the right to nominate another person, and a person openly acting as an agent for an unidentified principal.

 

These distinctions matter because different arrangements can produce different legal consequences. The mere fact that someone intends to benefit another person through a transaction does not, by itself, establish an undisclosed principal relationship.


The doctrine may also be excluded where the terms of the agreement, properly interpreted, are inconsistent with the involvement of an undisclosed principal, or where the identity of the contracting party is material to the transaction. For example, where a contract is concluded specifically because of the personal qualities, expertise or identity of the agent, an undisclosed principal may not necessarily be entitled to enforce it.


How can businesses reduce uncertainty?

Businesses and individuals can reduce the risk of disputes by ensuring that contractual arrangements accurately reflect the intended relationship between the parties.

 

Depending on the transaction, practical steps may include:

  • Clarifying the contracting parties: Where a person is acting for another, consider whether the principal should be identified in the agreement.

  • Defining the person's capacity: State clearly whether the person is contracting personally, acting as a representative, or entering into the agreement under another arrangement.

  • Confirming authority: Where a person is acting as an agent, establish whether they have the necessary authority to act on behalf of the principal.

  • Recording the commercial arrangement: Ensure that the written agreement accurately reflects the parties' intentions, responsibilities and expectations.

 

These measures can help prevent uncertainty about who is entitled to enforce the agreement and who is responsible for performing its obligations.


Conclusion

 

The doctrine of the undisclosed principal demonstrates that contractual relationships cannot always be determined solely by looking at the names appearing on an agreement. In appropriate circumstances, a person who was not disclosed when the contract was concluded may nevertheless acquire rights or incur obligations under it.

 

For businesses and individuals, the key lesson is to pay careful attention to the capacity in which a person contracts and the legal relationship the parties intend to create. Where the position is unclear, obtaining legal advice before entering into the transaction can help prevent costly disputes later.

 

Zinhle Skosana

LLB

Candidate Attorney at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys


Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page