top of page
Untitled (A2 (Landscape))_Nero_AI_Image_Upscaler_Photo_Face.png

LE ROUX VIVIER ATTORNEYS

Where There's a Will, There’s a Way to Lose It: What Makes a Will Invalid in South Africa?

Writer: lerouxvivierattorn
lerouxvivierattorn
6 days ago
9 min read

A will may be invalid or unenforceable under South African law for several reasons. These include non-compliance with the formalities prescribed by the Wills Act 7 of 1953 (“Wills Act”), a lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud or duress, and provisions that are unlawful or contrary to public policy.


Formalities: Sign here, here and here

Section 2(1)(a) of the Wills Act sets out the formalities for a valid will. Although generally strictly applied, non-compliance may be condoned by the High Court under section 2(3). The principal requirements are:

 

The will must be in writing:

  • An oral declaration is not ordinarily a valid will.

  • Section 4(4) of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act 25 of 2002, read with Schedule 2, excludes wills and codicils from its general electronic-transaction provisions.

  • An email or electronic document recording testamentary intentions is therefore not automatically a formally valid will, although a court may recognise it under section 2(3).

 

The testator must sign at the end:

  • The testator must sign the will at its end, or another person may sign on the testator's behalf in the testator's presence and at their direction.

  • A substantial gap between the concluding provisions and the signature may raise questions about compliance.

 

Two competent witnesses must be present simultaneously:

  • The testator must sign, or acknowledge an existing signature, in the simultaneous presence of at least two competent witnesses.

  • The witnesses must sign in the presence of the testator and one another.

  • A competent witness is at least 14 years old and competent to give evidence in court. Independent adult witnesses are preferable.

 

Each page must be signed:

  • For a multi-page will, the testator must sign every page, with the final-page signature at the end of the will.

 

Additional requirements apply where the testator signs by mark or another person signs on their behalf:

  • Under section 2(1)(a)(v), a commissioner of oaths must certify the testator’s identity and that the document is their will.

  • The commissioner must sign the certificate and each page, observing the Act’s requirements as to timing, placement and the testator’s presence.

 

Amendments made after execution must comply with section 2(1)(b), including the prescribed signatures of the testator (or a person signing on their behalf) and two competent witnesses.

 

Additional certification is required for a mark or signature on the testator’s behalf. A defective amendment may be invalid, subject to possible condonation under section 2(3).

 

Under section 2(3), the court must be satisfied that the deceased drafted or executed the document and intended it to be their will or an amendment. The evidence and applicable case law are decisive.

 

The courts have clarified the limits of this remedy:

 

Bekker v Naudé en Andere 2003 (5) SA 173 (SCA):

  • The Supreme Court of Appeal considered the meaning of the requirement that the deceased must have “drafted or executed” the document.

  • The judgment emphasised the importance of establishing the deceased's personal involvement in drafting or executing the document.

  • Mere approval of a document prepared by another person, without the necessary involvement by the deceased, is insufficient to satisfy the statutory requirements.

 

Van der Merwe v Master of the High Court and Another 2010 (6) SA 544 (SCA):

  • The Supreme Court of Appeal recognised that an electronic document may, in appropriate circumstances, satisfy the requirements for condonation under section 2(3).

  • The decision demonstrates that the absence of a conventional handwritten signature does not necessarily prevent a document from being accepted as a will, provided the statutory requirements are established by the evidence.

 

MacDonald and Others v The Master and Others 2002 (5) SA 64 (O):

  • The court considered whether an electronic document stored on the deceased's computer could be recognised as a will despite non-compliance with the ordinary execution formalities.

  • The decision illustrates the potential application of section 2(3) to electronic documents where the deceased's testamentary intention and the other statutory requirements can be established.

 

Condonation entails a court application, evidence and costs. It is a safety net, not a substitute for proper execution.


Of sound mind and signature: Testamentary capacity

 

In terms of section 4 of the Wills Act, a person aged 16 years or older may make a will unless, at the time of making it, they are mentally incapable of appreciating the nature and effect of their act. A person younger than 16 does not have the statutory capacity to execute a valid will.

 

Testamentary capacity is assessed at the time the will is made. The burden of proving that the testator lacked the necessary mental capacity rests on the person alleging incapacity. Advanced age, illness or unusual behaviour does not, without more, establish a lack of testamentary capacity.

 

Where concerns exist regarding a testator's mental capacity, obtaining an appropriate medical assessment contemporaneously with the execution of the will may provide valuable evidence should its validity later be challenged.

 

Whose will is it anyway?  Undue influence, fraud, duress and mistake

A valid will must reflect the testator's genuine and independent testamentary intentions. A will, or a particular provision, may be challenged where it is alleged that the testator's freedom of decision was improperly interfered with or that the document does not accurately reflect their intentions.

 

The challenger generally bears the burden of proof. Courts consider the circumstances of preparation and execution, relationships between those involved, and any independent advice.

 

Undue influence: Influence exerted over a testator may invalidate a will where it is established that the testator's freedom of decision was overborne and that the resulting testamentary disposition did not reflect their independent wishes. Ordinary persuasion, advice or expressions of affection do not, without more, constitute undue influence.

 

Fraud or forgery: Examples include a forged signature, substituted page or a will procured through deliberate deception.

 

Duress: Threats that compel the testator to sign.

 

Mistake: A mistake may affect the validity or interpretation of a will where it can be established that the document signed does not reflect the testator's actual intentions. For example, difficulties may arise where spouses inadvertently sign each other's wills. The legal consequences depend on the nature of the mistake, the surrounding circumstances and the relief sought from the court.


Witnesses should watch, not win: section 4A

Section 4A of the Wills Act provides that certain persons involved in the execution or preparation of a will may be disqualified from receiving benefits under it. This does not ordinarily invalidate the will itself, but may affect the entitlement of particular beneficiaries.

 

In terms of section 4A(1), a person who signs a will as a witness, signs on behalf of the testator, or writes out the will or any part of it in their own handwriting may be disqualified from receiving a benefit under that will. The spouse of such a person, at the time of execution of the will, may also be disqualified.

 

However, section 4A(2) provides important exceptions. A court may declare a disqualified person competent to receive a benefit if satisfied that the person did not defraud or unduly influence the testator in the execution of the will. Furthermore, a disqualified person may receive a benefit to the extent that its value does not exceed what they would have received had the testator died intestate.

 

An additional exception applies where a person who would otherwise be disqualified acted as a witness and the will was also witnessed by at least two other competent witnesses who are not similarly disqualified.

 

The safest approach is to use independent witnesses who are neither beneficiaries nor their spouses.


A change of heart, a change of will: Revocation

 

A subsequent valid will may expressly revoke an earlier will or revoke it by implication to the extent that its provisions are inconsistent with those of the earlier will. An express revocation clause is generally preferable, as it reduces uncertainty concerning which testamentary provisions remain operative.

 

A will may be revoked through its intentional destruction by the testator, provided the necessary intention to revoke is established. The accidental loss or destruction of a will does not, by itself, establish revocation. However, where an original will cannot be located after the testator's death, questions may arise concerning whether it was deliberately destroyed and whether its contents and continued validity can be established.

 

Section 2A of the Wills Act empowers the High Court, in specified circumstances, to declare a will or part of a will revoked where the deceased’s intention to revoke is established. The section applies to particular acts or documents contemplated by the legislation, including a written indication of revocation and certain acts performed in relation to the will. The court must be satisfied that the deceased intended the relevant will or provision to be revoked.

 

Under section 2B, if a testator dies within three months after divorce or annulment, a pre-existing will generally operates as if the former spouse had died first, unless the will indicates an intention to benefit that spouse despite the dissolution. After three months, the will generally governs.

 

Freedom of testation is not a free-for-all

South African law recognises and protects the principle of freedom of testation, which generally allows a person to determine how their estate should devolve upon death. However, this freedom is not absolute.

 

Testamentary provisions may be invalid or unenforceable where they are unlawful, impossible to implement, insufficiently certain or contrary to public policy, including public policy informed by constitutional values.

 

Whether a particular provision is enforceable depends on its wording, purpose and surrounding circumstances.

 

King NO and Others v De Jager and Others 2021 (4) SA 1 (CC):

  • The Constitutional Court considered a testamentary fideicommissary provision that restricted succession to male descendants, thereby excluding female descendants.

  • The Court held that the discriminatory provision was contrary to public policy as informed by constitutional values, including equality and non-discrimination.

  • The judgment demonstrates that freedom of testation does not provide unrestricted protection for discriminatory testamentary provisions.

 

Minister of Education v Syfrets Trust Ltd 2006 (4) SA 205 (C) and Curators, Emma Smith Educational Fund v University of KwaZulu-Natal 2010 (6) SA 518 (SCA):

  • The courts removed race-based restrictions in charitable bursary trusts.

 

Ex parte BOE Trust Ltd 2013 (3) SA 236 (SCA):

  • The Supreme Court of Appeal considered the extent to which courts may interfere with testamentary provisions on public-policy grounds.

  • The judgment illustrates the importance of freedom of testation and the need for a careful assessment of the particular circumstances before a court interferes with a testator's expressed wishes.

  • Not every distinction between potential beneficiaries will necessarily render a testamentary provision contrary to public policy.

 

As a general principle, a testator may not delegate the essential power to determine the beneficiaries of their estate to another person. However, the law recognises limited circumstances in which a testator may confer a power of appointment or selection upon another person, particularly where the potential beneficiaries are sufficiently defined. The permissible scope of such powers was considered in Braun v Blann and Botha 1984 (2) SA 850 (A).

 

Where a particular testamentary provision is found to be invalid or unenforceable, the remaining provisions of the will may continue to operate, provided they are capable of standing independently and giving effect to the testator's lawful intentions.

 

The destination of the affected benefit will depend on the wording and structure of the will, including any applicable residuary provision, and may ultimately be determined in accordance with the rules of intestate succession.


Will-power: Getting it right the first time
 

Sign at the end of the will and on each preceding page, in the simultaneous presence of at least two competent witnesses. Use independent adults who are not beneficiaries or their spouses, and ensure everyone signs in the required presence.

 

Date the will, although a date is not legally required.

 

Where changes are required, it is generally advisable to execute a new will or a properly executed codicil rather than making handwritten alterations to an existing will. Any amendments must comply with the applicable statutory formalities to avoid uncertainty or disputes concerning their validity.

 

Store the original signed will in a secure location and ensure that the nominated executor or another trusted person knows where it can be found. Although the original will is ordinarily required for the administration of a deceased estate, the absence of the original does not necessarily mean that the deceased's testamentary wishes cannot be given effect.

 

Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to establish the existence, contents and continued validity of a lost or destroyed will through appropriate evidence and legal proceedings.

 

Review the will after marriage, divorce, the birth of a child or a significant change in assets.


Sources

  • Wills Act 7 of 1953, section 4A (acts.co.za)

  • King NO v De Jager [2021] ZACC 4 (SAFLII)

  • Blom v Brown [2011] ZASCA 54

  • Ex parte Pretorius [2017] ZAWCHC 11 (SAFLII)

  • Van der Linde, Requirements in terms of section 2(3) of the Wills Act, De Jure (2012)

  • Schoeman-Malan, Condonation confusion, Journal for Juridical Science (2017)

 

Sharon Honiball

LLB

Partner at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys


Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page