
THINK LEGAL. THINK LVA.
Search this site
31 results found with an empty search
- Behind the Contract: The Undisclosed Principal
Can a person enter into a contract in their own name while acting for someone else? Under certain circumstances, South African law recognises the doctrine of the undisclosed principal, which can affect who has rights and obligations under a contract. When entering into a commercial agreement, it is natural to assume that the parties to the contract are the people or businesses expressly identified in it. However, the law of agency recognises circumstances in which a person contracts in their own name while acting on behalf of another person whose involvement is not disclosed to the other contracting party. This raises an important question: if the true principal is not identified when the contract is concluded, can that principal later enforce the contract or be held liable under it? What is an undisclosed principal? An undisclosed principal is a person on whose behalf another person (referred to as an “agent”) enters into a contract in their own name, without revealing that they are acting as an agent. In an ordinary agency arrangement, an agent acts as a representative of a principal. The agent concludes a contract on the principal's behalf, and the rights and obligations arising from that contract ordinarily belong to the principal rather than the agent. The position is different where the principal is undisclosed. The agent does not present themselves as a representative of another person but contracts in their own name. The third party may therefore believe that they are dealing directly with the person who will acquire the contractual rights and obligations. The doctrine of the undisclosed principal recognises that, in appropriate circumstances, the undisclosed principal may nevertheless acquire rights and incur obligations under the contract, despite not having been identified as a contracting party. Importantly, the agent may also remain personally liable under the contract, notwithstanding the existence of an undisclosed principal. When does the Undisclosed Principal Doctrine apply? The doctrine does not apply merely because a person secretly hopes to benefit from a contract or because someone else concludes an agreement on their behalf. Certain requirements must be established. First, the agent must have been authorised or mandated to conclude the contract on behalf of the principal. There must be a sufficient basis for establishing that the agent was acting on the principal's behalf and with the necessary authority at the time the contract was concluded. The principal's mere knowledge of the transaction, or the fact that the principal stands to benefit from it, is not enough. Second, the agent must contract in their own name without disclosing that they are acting in a representative capacity. The other contracting party must understand the agent to be contracting on their own account, rather than being told that they are acting as an agent for someone else. This is what distinguishes an undisclosed principal from an unnamed principal. Whether the undisclosed principal doctrine applies must be determined with reference to the particular agreement and the circumstances in which it was concluded. The doctrine does not automatically give a person rights under, or impose obligations arising from, every contract entered into by another person. A practical example Thabo wishes to purchase specialised machinery for his business but prefers not to reveal his involvement in the transaction. He therefore authorises Naledi to negotiate with a supplier and purchase the machinery on his behalf. Naledi enters into the sale agreement in her own name without disclosing that she is acting for Thabo. The supplier believes that Naledi is purchasing the machinery for herself, unaware that she is acting on behalf of Thabo. If the requirements of the undisclosed principal doctrine are satisfied, Thabo may enforce the contract directly against the supplier, despite not having been identified as a contracting party when the agreement was concluded. Similarly, Thabo may incur obligations under the contract, while Naledi may remain personally liable. This is a recognised exception to the general principle of privity of contract, which ordinarily provides that only parties to a contract may enforce rights arising from it. The doctrine allows an undisclosed principal to institute legal proceedings in their own name without first requiring the agent to cede the contractual rights to them. For example, if the supplier fails to deliver the machinery, Thabo may institute proceedings against the supplier in his own name, provided he can establish that Naledi was authorised to contract on his behalf and that the requirements of the doctrine have been met. The supplier may, however, raise any applicable contractual defences arising from its dealings with Naledi. This example illustrates why identifying the parties entitled to enforce a contract, or those responsible for its obligations, is not always as straightforward as examining the names appearing on the agreement. How does an undisclosed principal differ from an unnamed principal? The distinction between an undisclosed principal and an unnamed principal is particularly important. Where a person acts for an unnamed principal, they openly indicate that they are acting in a representative capacity but do not identify the principal. The other contracting party knows that the agent is acting for someone else, even though that person's identity is not revealed. With an undisclosed principal, the person contracts in their own name without disclosing that they are acting for another person at all. The distinction concerns more than terminology. It affects how the parties' conduct and intentions are understood and how the applicable principles of agency operate. Why does the doctrine matter? The doctrine can have significant consequences for both the person who enters into the contract and the person whose interests they represent. 1. Contractual rights and obligations An undisclosed principal may, where the doctrine applies, be entitled to enforce the contract in their own name or be held liable for obligations arising from it. The fact that the principal was not disclosed at the time of contracting does not necessarily prevent this outcome. Similarly, the agent may remain personally liable under the agreement, meaning that the third party may have remedies against both the agent and the undisclosed principal, subject to the applicable legal principles. 2. The position of the contracting party A supplier, service provider or other contracting party may believe that they are dealing with one person, only to discover that another person claims rights or is alleged to bear obligations under the agreement. This can create uncertainty, particularly where the identity or financial position of the true principal would have influenced the decision to contract. 3. Disputes about the parties' intentions The circumstances in which the agreement was concluded may become important. The court may need to consider whether the person was genuinely acting on behalf of a specific principal, whether the arrangement falls within the doctrine, and what the parties intended to achieve through their dealings. The doctrine should therefore not be treated as an automatic means of adding another party to an existing contract. Its application depends on the relevant facts and legal requirements. Does the doctrine apply to every contract? No. The existence of an undisclosed principal does not automatically mean that the principal can enforce or be held liable under every agreement concluded by another person. The nature of the transaction, the parties' intentions and the circumstances surrounding the conclusion of the contract must be considered. The doctrine must also be distinguished from other legal arrangements, including a person contracting for their own account while reserving the right to nominate another person, and a person openly acting as an agent for an unidentified principal. These distinctions matter because different arrangements can produce different legal consequences. The mere fact that someone intends to benefit another person through a transaction does not, by itself, establish an undisclosed principal relationship. The doctrine may also be excluded where the terms of the agreement, properly interpreted, are inconsistent with the involvement of an undisclosed principal, or where the identity of the contracting party is material to the transaction. For example, where a contract is concluded specifically because of the personal qualities, expertise or identity of the agent, an undisclosed principal may not necessarily be entitled to enforce it. How can businesses reduce uncertainty? Businesses and individuals can reduce the risk of disputes by ensuring that contractual arrangements accurately reflect the intended relationship between the parties. Depending on the transaction, practical steps may include: Clarifying the contracting parties: Where a person is acting for another, consider whether the principal should be identified in the agreement. Defining the person's capacity: State clearly whether the person is contracting personally, acting as a representative, or entering into the agreement under another arrangement. Confirming authority: Where a person is acting as an agent, establish whether they have the necessary authority to act on behalf of the principal. Recording the commercial arrangement: Ensure that the written agreement accurately reflects the parties' intentions, responsibilities and expectations. These measures can help prevent uncertainty about who is entitled to enforce the agreement and who is responsible for performing its obligations. Conclusion The doctrine of the undisclosed principal demonstrates that contractual relationships cannot always be determined solely by looking at the names appearing on an agreement. In appropriate circumstances, a person who was not disclosed when the contract was concluded may nevertheless acquire rights or incur obligations under it. For businesses and individuals, the key lesson is to pay careful attention to the capacity in which a person contracts and the legal relationship the parties intend to create. Where the position is unclear, obtaining legal advice before entering into the transaction can help prevent costly disputes later. Zinhle Skosana LLB Candidate Attorney at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Appropriation of Payments: Who Decides Which Debt Gets Paid?
If you owe someone money under more than one obligation and make a payment without specifying what it is for, which debt does that payment settle? Is it automatically applied to the oldest outstanding amount? The answer is not necessarily. South African common law recognises rules governing the appropriation of payments, which determine how a payment is allocated when a debtor owes multiple debts to the same creditor. Importantly, the oldest debt is not automatically settled first in every situation. What is the Appropriation of Payments? Appropriation of payments refers to the allocation of a payment towards a particular debt or outstanding amount. The issue arises where a debtor owes more than one debt to the same creditor and makes a payment without clearly indicating which debt it is intended to settle. Those debts may arise from separate agreements or from different obligations under the same agreement. For example, suppose Sipho owes a creditor R10,000 under a loan agreement and a further R5,000 for services rendered. If Sipho pays R5,000 without identifying which debt the payment relates to, the question arises as to how that payment should be allocated. Who Decides Which Debt is Paid? The parties may agree contractually how payments are to be appropriated. Where an agreement contains an enforceable provision governing the allocation of payments, that provision will generally prevail over the ordinary common-law rules. In the absence of such an agreement, South African common law establishes the following order of preference for determining how a payment is appropriated. 1. The debtor may appropriate the payment A debtor who owes more than one debt to the same creditor may indicate, expressly or tacitly, which debt a payment is intended to settle. This is known as appropriation by the debtor. In the absence of a contrary contractual arrangement or applicable legal rule, the creditor is generally bound by the debtor's appropriation and cannot unilaterally allocate the payment to a different debt. For example, a debtor may identify the relevant invoice or agreement in the payment reference or otherwise communicate which outstanding debt the payment is intended to discharge. 2. The creditor may appropriate the payment Where the debtor has not appropriated the payment, the creditor may generally appropriate it, subject to the applicable contractual arrangements and common-law requirements. The creditor's right to do so is subject to requirements. The appropriation must be made promptly and communicated to the debtor within a reasonable time. The creditor's discretion is also subject to limitations and may not be exercised inequitably. The respective rights of the debtor and creditor to appropriate payments, and the requirements governing the exercise of those rights, were considered in Standard Bank of SA Ltd v Oneanate Investments (Pty) Ltd 1995 (4) SA 510 (C). 3. If neither party appropriates the payment, common-law rules apply Where neither the debtor nor the creditor has appropriated the payment, the common-law rules determine how it should be allocated. The general principle is that the payment should be applied to the debt that is most onerous to the debtor, or the debt that it is most in the debtor's interest to discharge having regard to the particular circumstances. This principle was reaffirmed by the Supreme Court of Appeal in Miloc Financial Solutions (Pty) Ltd v Logistic Technologies (Pty) Ltd and Others 2008 (4) SA 325 (SCA). In that case, the debtor owed amounts under two separate agreements. A payment of R1 million had to be allocated between a remaining R500,000 balance under one agreement and R4 million owing under another. The court considered which debt it was more beneficial for the debtor to discharge. Paying the R500,000 balance would release shares that had been pledged as security. Those shares could then be used to raise finance towards settling the larger debt. By contrast, applying the payment to the R4 million debt would only reduce that amount without releasing the pledged shares. The court accordingly held that the payment should be allocated to the R500,000 balance because discharging that debt was more advantageous to the debtor. This illustrates why the oldest outstanding debt is not necessarily the first debt to which a payment must be allocated. Are There Other Rules to Consider? Although the most onerous debt or the debt most beneficial to the debtor is the general residual principle, other rules may apply in particular circumstances. 1. Interest before capital Where capital and interest are owing as components of the same debt, payments are generally applied towards outstanding interest before reducing the capital amount. This rule was confirmed by the Supreme Court of Appeal in Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Oneanate Investments (Pty) Ltd 1998 (1) SA 811 (SCA). The court distinguished between competing capital debts and the allocation of payments between the capital and interest components of the same debt. It held that the latter situation is governed by the rule that payment is first applied to interest and thereafter to capital. It is important not to confuse this rule with the allocation of a payment between separate debts. The interest-before-capital rule concerns the allocation of a payment within the same indebtedness. 2. The first-in-first-out rule and bank accounts The first-in-first-out approach is associated with Devaynes v Noble; Clayton's Case (1816) 1 Mer 572. Broadly, it involves applying the first credit against the earliest debit in a running account. However, it would be incorrect to present this as a universal rule governing all payments into bank accounts under South African law. In Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Oneanate Investments (Pty) Ltd 1998 (1) SA 811 (SCA), the Supreme Court of Appeal considered the application of Clayton's Case to a bank overdraft. It rejected the approach adopted by the court in Clayton's Case, distinguishing between the allocation of payments among separate debts and the allocation of payments towards the interest and capital owed under a single debt. Accordingly, the Clayton's Case approach should not be treated as an automatic rule for every bank account or every situation involving multiple debts. The circumstances of the account and the nature of the amounts being allocated remain important. 3. Appropriation of payments and prescription The appropriation of a payment may also have implications for prescription. Under section 14 of the Prescription Act 68 of 1969, prescription is interrupted by an express or tacit acknowledgment of liability by the debtor. A payment towards an outstanding debt may, depending on the circumstances, constitute such an acknowledgment. Where a debtor owes multiple debts to the same creditor, the debt to which the payment is appropriated may therefore be relevant in determining which obligation has been acknowledged and whether prescription has been interrupted. However, a payment towards one debt does not necessarily interrupt prescription in respect of other debts owed to the same creditor. The effect will depend on the circumstances and whether the debtor's conduct amounts to an acknowledgment of liability in respect of the particular debt. Why Does the Appropriation of Payments Matter? The way a payment is allocated can affect the amount that remains outstanding under an agreement, the interest that continues to accrue and the creditor's ability to enforce payment. For debtors, failing to identify the debt being paid may result in a payment being allocated differently from what was intended. For creditors, an appropriation made without proper regard to the applicable rules may give rise to disputes about the outstanding balance. To reduce uncertainty, both parties should: Identify the specific debt or invoice to which a payment relates; Include a clear payment reference when making electronic payments; Record any agreed allocation in writing; Check how payments have been allocated when reviewing statements of account; and Raise any disagreement about the allocation of a payment promptly. Conclusion South African common law does not impose a universal rule that every payment must be applied to the oldest outstanding debt first. The parties may agree contractually how payments are to be allocated. In the absence of such an agreement, a debtor may ordinarily determine which debt a payment should settle. If the debtor does not do so, the creditor may have an opportunity to appropriate it, subject to certain requirements. Where neither party makes an appropriation, the payment is generally allocated to the debt that is most onerous or most beneficial for the debtor to discharge. The appropriation of payments can affect not only the outstanding balance and interest payable, but also the potential interruption of prescription. Understanding these principles can help both debtors and creditors avoid uncertainty, manage outstanding obligations and prevent unnecessary disputes. Zinhle Skosana LLB Candidate Attorney at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Where There's a Will, There’s a Way to Lose It: What Makes a Will Invalid in South Africa?
A will may be invalid or unenforceable under South African law for several reasons. These include non-compliance with the formalities prescribed by the Wills Act 7 of 1953 (“Wills Act”), a lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, fraud or duress, and provisions that are unlawful or contrary to public policy. Formalities: Sign here, here and here Section 2(1)(a) of the Wills Act sets out the formalities for a valid will. Although generally strictly applied, non-compliance may be condoned by the High Court under section 2(3). The principal requirements are: The will must be in writing: An oral declaration is not ordinarily a valid will. Section 4(4) of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act 25 of 2002, read with Schedule 2, excludes wills and codicils from its general electronic-transaction provisions. An email or electronic document recording testamentary intentions is therefore not automatically a formally valid will, although a court may recognise it under section 2(3). The testator must sign at the end: The testator must sign the will at its end, or another person may sign on the testator's behalf in the testator's presence and at their direction. A substantial gap between the concluding provisions and the signature may raise questions about compliance. Two competent witnesses must be present simultaneously: The testator must sign, or acknowledge an existing signature, in the simultaneous presence of at least two competent witnesses. The witnesses must sign in the presence of the testator and one another. A competent witness is at least 14 years old and competent to give evidence in court. Independent adult witnesses are preferable. Each page must be signed: For a multi-page will, the testator must sign every page, with the final-page signature at the end of the will. Additional requirements apply where the testator signs by mark or another person signs on their behalf: Under section 2(1)(a)(v), a commissioner of oaths must certify the testator’s identity and that the document is their will. The commissioner must sign the certificate and each page, observing the Act’s requirements as to timing, placement and the testator’s presence. Amendments made after execution must comply with section 2(1)(b), including the prescribed signatures of the testator (or a person signing on their behalf) and two competent witnesses. Additional certification is required for a mark or signature on the testator’s behalf. A defective amendment may be invalid, subject to possible condonation under section 2(3). Under section 2(3), the court must be satisfied that the deceased drafted or executed the document and intended it to be their will or an amendment. The evidence and applicable case law are decisive. The courts have clarified the limits of this remedy: Bekker v Naudé en Andere 2003 (5) SA 173 (SCA): The Supreme Court of Appeal considered the meaning of the requirement that the deceased must have “drafted or executed” the document. The judgment emphasised the importance of establishing the deceased's personal involvement in drafting or executing the document. Mere approval of a document prepared by another person, without the necessary involvement by the deceased, is insufficient to satisfy the statutory requirements. Van der Merwe v Master of the High Court and Another 2010 (6) SA 544 (SCA): The Supreme Court of Appeal recognised that an electronic document may, in appropriate circumstances, satisfy the requirements for condonation under section 2(3). The decision demonstrates that the absence of a conventional handwritten signature does not necessarily prevent a document from being accepted as a will, provided the statutory requirements are established by the evidence. MacDonald and Others v The Master and Others 2002 (5) SA 64 (O): The court considered whether an electronic document stored on the deceased's computer could be recognised as a will despite non-compliance with the ordinary execution formalities. The decision illustrates the potential application of section 2(3) to electronic documents where the deceased's testamentary intention and the other statutory requirements can be established. Condonation entails a court application, evidence and costs. It is a safety net, not a substitute for proper execution. Of sound mind and signature: Testamentary capacity In terms of section 4 of the Wills Act, a person aged 16 years or older may make a will unless, at the time of making it, they are mentally incapable of appreciating the nature and effect of their act. A person younger than 16 does not have the statutory capacity to execute a valid will. Testamentary capacity is assessed at the time the will is made. The burden of proving that the testator lacked the necessary mental capacity rests on the person alleging incapacity. Advanced age, illness or unusual behaviour does not, without more, establish a lack of testamentary capacity. Where concerns exist regarding a testator's mental capacity, obtaining an appropriate medical assessment contemporaneously with the execution of the will may provide valuable evidence should its validity later be challenged. Whose will is it anyway? Undue influence, fraud, duress and mistake A valid will must reflect the testator's genuine and independent testamentary intentions. A will, or a particular provision, may be challenged where it is alleged that the testator's freedom of decision was improperly interfered with or that the document does not accurately reflect their intentions. The challenger generally bears the burden of proof. Courts consider the circumstances of preparation and execution, relationships between those involved, and any independent advice. Undue influence: Influence exerted over a testator may invalidate a will where it is established that the testator's freedom of decision was overborne and that the resulting testamentary disposition did not reflect their independent wishes. Ordinary persuasion, advice or expressions of affection do not, without more, constitute undue influence. Fraud or forgery: Examples include a forged signature, substituted page or a will procured through deliberate deception. Duress: Threats that compel the testator to sign. Mistake: A mistake may affect the validity or interpretation of a will where it can be established that the document signed does not reflect the testator's actual intentions. For example, difficulties may arise where spouses inadvertently sign each other's wills. The legal consequences depend on the nature of the mistake, the surrounding circumstances and the relief sought from the court. Witnesses should watch, not win: section 4A Section 4A of the Wills Act provides that certain persons involved in the execution or preparation of a will may be disqualified from receiving benefits under it. This does not ordinarily invalidate the will itself, but may affect the entitlement of particular beneficiaries. In terms of section 4A(1), a person who signs a will as a witness, signs on behalf of the testator, or writes out the will or any part of it in their own handwriting may be disqualified from receiving a benefit under that will. The spouse of such a person, at the time of execution of the will, may also be disqualified. However, section 4A(2) provides important exceptions. A court may declare a disqualified person competent to receive a benefit if satisfied that the person did not defraud or unduly influence the testator in the execution of the will. Furthermore, a disqualified person may receive a benefit to the extent that its value does not exceed what they would have received had the testator died intestate. An additional exception applies where a person who would otherwise be disqualified acted as a witness and the will was also witnessed by at least two other competent witnesses who are not similarly disqualified. The safest approach is to use independent witnesses who are neither beneficiaries nor their spouses. A change of heart, a change of will: Revocation A subsequent valid will may expressly revoke an earlier will or revoke it by implication to the extent that its provisions are inconsistent with those of the earlier will. An express revocation clause is generally preferable, as it reduces uncertainty concerning which testamentary provisions remain operative. A will may be revoked through its intentional destruction by the testator, provided the necessary intention to revoke is established. The accidental loss or destruction of a will does not, by itself, establish revocation. However, where an original will cannot be located after the testator's death, questions may arise concerning whether it was deliberately destroyed and whether its contents and continued validity can be established. Section 2A of the Wills Act empowers the High Court, in specified circumstances, to declare a will or part of a will revoked where the deceased’s intention to revoke is established. The section applies to particular acts or documents contemplated by the legislation, including a written indication of revocation and certain acts performed in relation to the will. The court must be satisfied that the deceased intended the relevant will or provision to be revoked. Under section 2B, if a testator dies within three months after divorce or annulment, a pre-existing will generally operates as if the former spouse had died first, unless the will indicates an intention to benefit that spouse despite the dissolution. After three months, the will generally governs. Freedom of testation is not a free-for-all South African law recognises and protects the principle of freedom of testation, which generally allows a person to determine how their estate should devolve upon death. However, this freedom is not absolute. Testamentary provisions may be invalid or unenforceable where they are unlawful, impossible to implement, insufficiently certain or contrary to public policy, including public policy informed by constitutional values. Whether a particular provision is enforceable depends on its wording, purpose and surrounding circumstances. King NO and Others v De Jager and Others 2021 (4) SA 1 (CC): The Constitutional Court considered a testamentary fideicommissary provision that restricted succession to male descendants, thereby excluding female descendants. The Court held that the discriminatory provision was contrary to public policy as informed by constitutional values, including equality and non-discrimination. The judgment demonstrates that freedom of testation does not provide unrestricted protection for discriminatory testamentary provisions. Minister of Education v Syfrets Trust Ltd 2006 (4) SA 205 (C) and Curators, Emma Smith Educational Fund v University of KwaZulu-Natal 2010 (6) SA 518 (SCA): The courts removed race-based restrictions in charitable bursary trusts. Ex parte BOE Trust Ltd 2013 (3) SA 236 (SCA): The Supreme Court of Appeal considered the extent to which courts may interfere with testamentary provisions on public-policy grounds. The judgment illustrates the importance of freedom of testation and the need for a careful assessment of the particular circumstances before a court interferes with a testator's expressed wishes. Not every distinction between potential beneficiaries will necessarily render a testamentary provision contrary to public policy. As a general principle, a testator may not delegate the essential power to determine the beneficiaries of their estate to another person. However, the law recognises limited circumstances in which a testator may confer a power of appointment or selection upon another person, particularly where the potential beneficiaries are sufficiently defined. The permissible scope of such powers was considered in Braun v Blann and Botha 1984 (2) SA 850 (A). Where a particular testamentary provision is found to be invalid or unenforceable, the remaining provisions of the will may continue to operate, provided they are capable of standing independently and giving effect to the testator's lawful intentions. The destination of the affected benefit will depend on the wording and structure of the will, including any applicable residuary provision, and may ultimately be determined in accordance with the rules of intestate succession. Will-power: Getting it right the first time Sign at the end of the will and on each preceding page, in the simultaneous presence of at least two competent witnesses. Use independent adults who are not beneficiaries or their spouses, and ensure everyone signs in the required presence. Date the will, although a date is not legally required. Where changes are required, it is generally advisable to execute a new will or a properly executed codicil rather than making handwritten alterations to an existing will. Any amendments must comply with the applicable statutory formalities to avoid uncertainty or disputes concerning their validity. Store the original signed will in a secure location and ensure that the nominated executor or another trusted person knows where it can be found. Although the original will is ordinarily required for the administration of a deceased estate, the absence of the original does not necessarily mean that the deceased's testamentary wishes cannot be given effect. Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to establish the existence, contents and continued validity of a lost or destroyed will through appropriate evidence and legal proceedings. Review the will after marriage, divorce, the birth of a child or a significant change in assets. Sources Wills Act 7 of 1953, section 4A (acts.co.za) King NO v De Jager [2021] ZACC 4 (SAFLII) Blom v Brown [2011] ZASCA 54 Ex parte Pretorius [2017] ZAWCHC 11 (SAFLII) Van der Linde, Requirements in terms of section 2(3) of the Wills Act, De Jure (2012) Schoeman-Malan, Condonation confusion, Journal for Juridical Science (2017) Sharon Honiball LLB Partner at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Can a Shareholder Be Forced to Sell Their Shares?
Compulsory Buy-Outs, Shareholder Deadlocks and Lessons from Recent Case Law Many businesses are founded on a shared vision, mutual trust and common goals. However, as businesses evolve, relationships between shareholders may deteriorate. Disagreements over management, profit distribution or control of the company can escalate to the point where shareholders can no longer work together. This raises an important question: Can a shareholder be compelled to sell their shares and exit the company simply because the relationship between shareholders has broken down? As with most legal questions, the answer depends on the circumstances. In this article, we explore when, and on what legal grounds, a shareholder may be compelled to sell their shares. SHAREHOLDER VS DIRECTOR Before considering whether a shareholder can be compelled to sell their shares, it is important to distinguish between a shareholder and a director. A shareholder holds an ownership interest in the company, whereas a director is responsible for participating in its management and oversight. In terms of section 66(1) of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 ("the Act"), the business and affairs of a company must be managed by or under the direction of its board of directors. Although a person may hold both positions, removing them as a director does not automatically affect their shareholding. For example, where two shareholders each own 50% of a company and one is removed as a director, that person retains their 50% shareholding unless their shares are lawfully transferred or otherwise dealt with in accordance with the applicable legal requirements. THE RELEVANCE OF SHAREHOLDERS' AGREEMENTS AND MOIs As a general rule, a shareholder cannot be compelled to sell their shares merely because the other shareholders no longer wish to remain in business with them. However, a properly drafted shareholders' agreement or Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI) may provide for circumstances in which a shareholder is required to offer or transfer their shares. For example, these documents may contain provisions dealing with: a shareholder's resignation or departure from the business; material breaches of the shareholders' agreement; the death, disability or insolvency of a shareholder; compulsory buy-out procedures; deadlock resolution mechanisms, including put and call options; the valuation of shares; and restrictions on transferring shares to third parties. Shareholders' agreements and MOIs may also contain drag-along and tag-along provisions. A drag-along provision may allow shareholders holding a specified majority to compel other shareholders to sell their shares as part of a qualifying sale transaction. Conversely, a tag-along provision generally protects minority shareholders by allowing them to participate in a proposed sale by other shareholders. These provisions can facilitate an orderly separation between shareholders and reduce the risk of costly litigation. However, their operation depends on their terms and enforceability. WHEN SAREHOLDES REACH AN IRRETRIEVABLE DEADLOCK In more serious cases, disagreements between shareholders may escalate to the point where they can no longer agree on important decisions or continue their business relationship. Section 81(1)(d) of the Act permits the winding-up of a solvent company by court order in specified circumstances. These include certain forms of deadlock between directors or shareholders, as contemplated in sections 81(1)(d)(i) and (ii), or where it is otherwise just and equitable to wind up the company under section 81(1)(d)(iii). Importantly, the just-and-equitable ground is not limited to circumstances where the company can no longer function. In appropriate cases, the irretrievable breakdown of mutual trust and confidence between shareholders in a closely held company may justify winding-up, even where the company remains financially solvent and operationally functional. However, winding-up is not the same as compelling a shareholder to sell their shares. It involves bringing the company's existence to an end through liquidation and may have significant consequences for its employees, creditors and business operations. COURT-ORDERED COMPULSORY BUY-OUTS Section 163 of the Act provides a remedy where a shareholder or director establishes that conduct falling within the scope of the section is oppressive, unfairly prejudicial or unfairly disregards their interests. Where the statutory requirements are satisfied, the Court has broad powers to grant appropriate relief. Importantly, section 163(2)(h) expressly empowers the Court to order the company or another person to purchase a shareholder's shares. However, the mere existence of a shareholder dispute or the breakdown of a business relationship does not automatically entitle a shareholder to relief under section 163. The applicant must establish conduct that satisfies the statutory requirements before the Court may exercise its discretion to grant an appropriate remedy. LESSONS FROM RECENT CASE LAW The Gauteng Division of the High Court, Pretoria, recently considered these issues in Hui Zhuang and Another v Empire Purification (Pty) Ltd and Others (Case No. 2025-031785, judgment delivered on 6 May 2026). The company was established as a joint venture between two groups of shareholders. Yulan Shi held 40% of the shares, while Cindy Henderson and Petru Henderson each held 30%. Hui Zhuang, although not a registered shareholder, had contributed financially to the business and claimed to be a creditor in respect of loans advanced to the company. Over time, the relationship between the parties deteriorated, resulting in disputes over the company's management, financial affairs and the proposed sale of shares. Despite exploring various buy-out arrangements, the parties could not agree on an acceptable separation. The minority shareholder and her husband subsequently applied for the winding-up of the company. The remaining shareholders opposed the application and brought a counter-application under section 163 of the Act, seeking an order compelling the minority shareholder to sell her shares. The Court dismissed the counter-application, finding that the respondents had failed to establish the statutory requirements for relief under section 163. In particular, the Court held that the applicants' exercise of their statutory right to seek liquidation did not, without more, constitute oppressive or unfairly prejudicial conduct. Significantly, the respondents' own attorneys had previously indicated, on two separate occasions, that liquidation appeared to be the appropriate course. The Court considered their subsequent attempt to resist liquidation and compel a buy-out to be inconsistent with their earlier position. The Court further found that the company operated as a quasi-partnership, founded on mutual trust and confidence between a small group of shareholders. That relationship had irretrievably broken down, and the parties had been unable to agree on a commercially acceptable separation. Accordingly, the Court dismissed the section 163 counter-application and granted a provisional winding-up order under section 81(1)(d)(iii) of the Act, finding that it was just and equitable to do so. The judgment demonstrates that although a court may order a compulsory share purchase under section 163, the breakdown of a business relationship does not, in itself, justify such an order. Where the statutory requirements for a compulsory buy-out are absent, but the relationship underpinning a closely held company has irretrievably broken down, winding-up on just-and-equitable grounds may instead be appropriate. WHAT SHOULD SHAREHOLDERS DO BEFORE APPROACHING COURT? Where shareholders can no longer work together, litigation need not be the first step. The parties should consider reviewing the company's MOI and shareholders' agreement to determine whether any contractual exit or deadlock resolution mechanisms apply. They may also explore a negotiated buy-out, obtain an independent share valuation or attempt to resolve the dispute through mediation. It is equally important to consider any outstanding shareholder loan accounts. A transfer of shares does not automatically extinguish amounts that the company may separately owe to the departing shareholder, and these obligations should be addressed as part of any proposed settlement. Taking these steps early may enable shareholders to reach a commercially viable resolution while preserving the value and continued operation of the business. CONCLUSION A shareholder cannot ordinarily be compelled to sell their shares merely because the relationship between shareholders has broken down. However, a valid shareholders' agreement, the company's MOI or an appropriate court order may provide a mechanism for a compulsory share transfer. The Empire Purification judgment illustrates that where shareholders can no longer work together, the consequences may extend beyond a dispute over ownership and ultimately threaten the continued existence of the company. Carefully drafted shareholders' agreements and MOIs, particularly those containing clear exit and deadlock resolution provisions, can help shareholders navigate disputes and avoid costly litigation. At Le Roux Vivier Attorneys, we assist companies, shareholders and directors with shareholders' agreements, Memoranda of Incorporation, share valuations and buy-out arrangements, shareholder disputes, corporate restructuring and commercial litigation. Ezekiel Dikio LLB Associate at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Asset-for-Share Transactions: Understanding Section 42
Transferring property, business assets or investments into a company can have significant tax consequences. Section 42 of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 (“the Act”) allows qualifying assets to be transferred without immediately triggering certain tax liabilities. However, the relief is subject to specific requirements, and careful planning is necessary to avoid unexpected tax consequences. What is an Asset-for-Share Transaction? A Section 42 asset-for-share transaction involves transferring an asset to a company in exchange for equity shares newly issued by that company. The shares, rather than a cash purchase price, form the consideration for the asset. The owner of the asset may be an individual, a company, a close corporation or a trust. Once the transaction is completed, the company owns the asset, while the former owner holds shares in the company. The main benefit is roll-over relief. Where a qualifying capital asset is transferred, the company takes over its historical base cost for Capital Gains Tax (CGT) purposes, and the shares received by the former owner acquire a corresponding base cost. The accrued capital gain is deferred, not written off. Which Assets Qualify? Section 42 is not limited to immovable property. It can apply to a wide range of assets, including residential and commercial property, shares in companies, machinery, business equipment, trading stock and intellectual property. An entire business may also be transferred, provided the relevant requirements are met. Different assets have different tax consequences. For example, selling machinery on which depreciation allowances have been claimed may result in taxable income, while selling shares that have increased in value may trigger CGT. Section 42 can provide relief from these immediate tax consequences, depending on the nature of the asset and whether the transaction qualifies. Certain assets are excluded, including personal goodwill and rights under a restraint-of-trade agreement. Personal goodwill is value attached to an individual’s reputation or relationships rather than to the business itself. A restraint of trade, such as an agreement not to compete with a business, cannot itself be transferred under Section 42. What are the Requirements? The requirements depend on the asset and the structure of the transaction. The principal requirements are: The asset must be transferred to a South African tax-resident company. The company must issue new equity shares in exchange for the asset. For capital assets, the market value must be at least equal to the base cost. For trading stock, the relevant tax-cost test applies. The company must acquire the asset as trading stock if the transferor held it as trading stock, or as a capital asset if the transferor held it as a capital asset. Section 42 also permits certain capital assets to be acquired as trading stock where the parties are not in the same group of companies. The person transferring the asset must generally hold a qualifying interest in the company at the end of the day on which the asset is disposed of. In an unlisted company, a qualifying interest usually requires at least 10% of the equity shares and 10% of the voting rights. Different rules apply to listed companies and certain group-company transactions. A natural person may also qualify by undertaking to render services full-time in the business of the company or a controlled group company. Other statutory conditions and exclusions may apply to particular transactions. What are Equity Shares? Section 42 requires the company to issue equity shares in exchange for the asset. Not all types of shares necessarily qualify. An equity share is broadly one that allows participation in dividends or capital beyond a specified amount. Ordinary shares normally qualify whereas shares whose dividend and capital entitlements are both capped at fixed amounts do not. The rights attached to the shares, not their name, determine whether they qualify. Example: Immovable Property Worth R5 Million Tom purchased a commercial property for R2 million. The property is now worth R5 million, and he wishes to transfer it to a company. If Tom sells the property for R5 million, he would ordinarily realise a capital gain of R3 million, assuming that R2 million is its tax base cost and that he holds it as a capital asset. At the maximum effective individual CGT rate of 18% (40% inclusion rate × 45% marginal tax rate), the CGT could be R540,000 before allowable expenses, exemptions or other adjustments. Alternatively, Tom transfers the property to the company in exchange for newly issued equity shares. If the Section 42 requirements are met, Tom does not pay CGT on the R3 million gain at the time of transfer. The company takes over the property’s R2 million base cost, while Tom’s shares acquire a corresponding base cost of R2 million. Base cost is used to calculate a capital gain and is not the asset’s current market value. The property and shares may each be worth R5 million, but their tax base costs remain R2 million. The R3 million gain has been deferred, not eliminated. What Happens on a Later Sale? If the company sells the property: If the company later sells the property for R6 million, it will realise a capital gain of R4 million (R6 million less its original base cost of R2 million). At the current effective company CGT rate of 21.6%, this could result in a tax liability of R864,000, before any applicable adjustments. The property’s R5 million value on the transfer date does not replace its R2 million base cost. If Tom sells his shares: If Tom subsequently sells all his shares for R5 million, he will realise a capital gain of R3 million (R5 million less his base cost of R2 million). At the maximum effective individual CGT rate of 18%, this could result in CGT of R540,000. If Tom sells only part of his shareholding, the gain is calculated on the shares sold. For example, assume Tom owns 100 identical shares worth R5 million, with a total base cost of R2 million. If he sells 40 shares for R2 million: The base cost of those 40 shares is R800,000. His capital gain is R1.2 million. His potential CGT liability at 18% is R216,000. The remaining 60 shares retain a combined base cost of R1.2 million. A sale within 18 months may also engage the special rules discussed below. Can both the company and Tom pay CGT? Yes. The company may incur CGT on a sale of the property, and Tom may separately incur CGT on a sale of his shares. These are different assets held by different taxpayers. Tax paid by the company can affect its net value and, in turn, the price a buyer is prepared to pay for Tom’s shares. Each disposal must therefore be assessed on its own facts. What About Existing Shareholers? A Section 42 transaction can affect the ownership and voting rights of existing shareholders, particularly where the company issues a substantial number of new shares. For example, Sarah and Peter each own 50% of a company worth R2 million. Their shares are therefore worth approximately R1 million each. Tom transfers a property worth R19 million to the company in exchange for newly issued ordinary shares. Assuming there are no other assets, liabilities or adjustments affecting the valuation, the company is now worth R21 million. If the shares are issued in proportion to the value Tom contributes, the shareholding would be approximately: Tom: 90.48% Sarah: 4.76% Peter: 4.76% Although Sarah and Peter's percentage ownership and voting rights have decreased significantly, their shares may still be worth approximately R1 million each. This is shareholder dilution - Their percentage ownership and voting rights fall, although the value of their shares does not necessarily fall. The First 18 Months: What Are the Risks? Section 42 contains anti-avoidance rules that can apply to transactions during the first 18 months. They do not impose a blanket prohibition on selling shares or assets, but may change the tax result. The following three rules are particularly relevant. Selling shares within 18 months — Section 42(5): Section 42(5) can apply where, immediately before the share disposal, more than 50% of the market value of the assets originally transferred under the relevant transactions is attributable to trading stock or allowance assets. For example, a trader transfers stock worth R1 million, which originally cost R400,000, to a company in exchange for shares. If the trader had sold the stock directly, the R600,000 profit would ordinarily have been taxable as income. If the trader sells the shares within 18 months, Section 42(5) may require the proceeds to be included in income to the extent that they do not exceed the market value of the shares at the beginning of that period. The rule applies only if its other statutory conditions are met. The rule is intended to prevent ordinary trading or allowance-related income from being converted into a more favourably taxed capital gain. It does not apply to every share sale within 18 months and specified exceptions also exist. Losing the qualifying interest — Section 42(6): For an unlisted company, the transferor will usually need to retain at least 10% of the equity shares and voting rights. For example, Tom transfers a property to a company and receives a 20% shareholding. His shares have a market value of R5 million and a tax base cost of R2 million. Six months later, the company issues additional shares to other shareholders, reducing Tom's shareholding to 8%. Although Tom has not sold any shares, he has fallen below the required 10% threshold. Section 42(6) can deem Tom to have disposed of and immediately reacquired the shares he still holds, using their market value on the date of the original asset-for-share transfer. On these assumed figures, the deemed disposal could trigger a R3 million capital gain even though Tom has received no sale proceeds. The shares are then deemed reacquired at that value for the relevant tax purposes. The same provision can apply where a person qualified on the basis of full-time services but ceases to meet that requirement within 18 months. Exceptions include specified corporate restructurings, involuntary disposals and death. The company selling the asset within 18 months — Section 42(7): Section 42(7) applies special rules when the company disposes of an asset within 18 months of acquiring it under Section 42. The treatment differs for capital assets, trading stock and allowance assets. For example, Tom transfers a property to a company under Section 42: Original base cost: R2 million. Market value when transferred: R5 million. Selling price six months later: R6 million. The company makes a total capital gain of R4 million. However, R3 million of that gain had already accumulated before Tom transferred the property to the company. Only the remaining R1 million arose after the transfer. For a capital asset, Section 42(7) separates the pre-transfer portion of the capital gain. In this example, that portion is R3 million. It is excluded from the company’s ordinary net capital-gain calculation, and the resulting taxable capital gain cannot be set off against its assessed losses. The remaining R1 million is dealt with under the ordinary CGT rules. This limits the use of a company’s tax losses to shelter gains that accrued before the asset was transferred. The sale is permitted, but it may result in a less favourable tax outcome. Transfer Duty: An Important Tax Benefit One of the significant benefits of Section 42, particularly when transferring immovable property, is the potential exemption from transfer duty. Ordinarily, when a company acquires immovable property, transfer duty may be payable unless the transaction is subject to VAT or qualifies for an exemption. For example, under the transfer-duty rates effective from 1 April 2026, an ordinary acquisition of property valued at R5 million would attract transfer duty of R327,356, assuming no exemption or VAT treatment applies. The Transfer Duty Act contains exemptions relevant to qualifying Section 42 transactions. Section 9(1)(l) exempts a company from transfer duty when it acquires property under a qualifying Section 42 asset-for-share transaction, provided its public officer makes a sworn affidavit or solemn declaration confirming compliance. Section 9(15A) also exempts an acquisition under Section 42 where the supplier and recipient are deemed to be one and the same person under Section 8(25) of the VAT Act. The company’s public officer must make a sworn affidavit or solemn declaration confirming that this VAT requirement is met. These exemptions can remove the transfer duty otherwise payable on the property acquisition. What If the Purchaser Is VAT-Registered? VAT registration alone does not establish whether transfer duty is payable. The VAT treatment of the particular property supply is what matters. Where the acquisition is subject to VAT, transfer duty does not ordinarily apply. If VAT does not apply, transfer duty may be payable unless an exemption is available. Section 42 does not itself make a transfer VAT-free. The parties must separately consider the VAT Act, including whether Section 8(25) applies. A transfer-duty exemption also does not remove conveyancing fees, Deeds Office charges or costs associated with mortgage bonds. Other Tax Considerations and Potential Risks Other aspects of the transaction may also affect its tax treatment. Existing loans and liabilities: If the transferor receives cash, a loan account or other consideration in addition to equity shares, Section 42(4) may exclude the corresponding portion of the transfer from roll-over relief. Section 42(8), however, accommodates specified assumed debts, including qualifying debt secured by the transferred asset and qualifying liabilities of a business transferred as a going concern. The nature, timing and security of any assumed debt must be examined. Qualifying assumed debt can also affect the tax treatment of the shares when they are subsequently disposed of. A transfer made solely in exchange for a loan account is not an asset-for-share transaction. Section 42(8A) also excludes certain transactions, including where the parties agree in writing not to apply Section 42, where the disposal has no specified tax consequences, or where the asset transferred is a debt owed by, or a share in, the acquiring company. The value of the shares issued: The value of the new shares should be considered alongside the market value of the asset transferred. A mismatch may trigger Section 24BA, subject to its specific conditions and exclusions. Securities Transfer Tax: Where the transferred asset consists of shares in another company, Securities Transfer Tax (STT) may be relevant. A qualifying Section 42 transaction may be exempt from STT, subject to the applicable requirements. Other unexpected tax consequences: A later disposal, share issue or change in the transferor’s interest can affect the tax relief, particularly during the first 18 months. These consequences should be considered before implementing the restructuring. Advantages and Disadvantages Advantages: Tax relief: A qualifying transfer may defer CGT and certain income-tax consequences. Transfer duty exemption: Transfers of immovable property may qualify for an exemption from transfer duty, resulting in substantial savings. Business restructuring: Property, investments or business assets can be placed in a company without an immediate tax charge on the qualifying transfer. Disadvantages: Deferred tax: The historical tax cost carries over, so tax may arise on a later disposal. Potential tax at two levels: The company may incur CGT when it sells the asset, while the shareholder may separately incur CGT when selling the shares. Shareholder dilution: Issuing new shares may reduce existing shareholders' percentage ownership and voting rights. 18-month rules: Certain early disposals or changes in shareholding can trigger unexpected tax liabilities. Costs and complexity: Valuations, financing arrangements, professional fees and compliance requirements can make the transaction costly or complicated. Conclusion Section 42 provides a valuable mechanism for transferring assets into a company without immediately incurring certain tax liabilities. However, the relief depends on meeting the statutory requirements, and the structure of the transaction can have significant tax consequences, both at the time of transfer and in the future. Le Roux Vivier Attorneys assists clients with the structuring and implementation of asset-for-share transactions and corporate reorganisations. Obtaining appropriate legal and tax advice before proceeding can help ensure that the transaction is structured correctly and that potential risks are identified. Disclaimer: This article provides general information as at November 2026 and does not constitute legal or tax advice. The examples are illustrative and do not account for all transaction-specific circumstances or tax adjustments. Fraser Stockley BCom Law; LLB Partner at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Going, Going, Gone: The Legalities Behind Auctions
There is something exciting about an auction — the anticipation, competitive bidding and the familiar call of “Going, going, gone!” But auctions are also governed by important legal rules, and a successful bid can have significant consequences. Whether you are bidding on a vehicle, machinery, immovable property or even shares in a company, it pays to understand the rules before you bid. The Law Behind the Hammer Auctions in South Africa are principally regulated by section 45 of the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 (CPA) and regulations 18 to 30 of the Consumer Protection Regulations. These provisions generally apply to auctions of both movable and immovable property and regulate matters such as advertising, bidding, reserve prices and the conduct of auctioneers. Other laws may also apply, including the Property Practitioners Act 22 of 2019, the Alienation of Land Act 68 of 1981, insolvency legislation and the court rules governing sales in execution. Where the CPA does not apply, an auction may still be governed by other legislation, the common law and the contractual arrangements between the parties. Can Anyone Conduct an Auction? Not necessarily. Although not every auctioneer is required to be professionally registered, the Consumer Protection Regulations prescribe requirements for auctioneers and disqualify certain persons, including unrehabilitated insolvents and persons convicted of specified offences involving dishonesty. Where the Property Practitioners Act applies, qualifying auctioneers and auction businesses must also comply with its registration and Fidelity Fund Certificate requirements. An auction house generally organises and administers auctions, while the auctioneer conducts the bidding. Both have legal responsibilities, including safeguarding property entrusted to them and complying with the applicable auction regulations. Auctioneers must also ensure that the Rules of Auction comply with the prescribed requirements, maintain proper bidding records and avoid misleading representations. Importantly, the individual auctioneer is expressly made personally accountable and liable for the contents of the Rules of Auction, even when conducting the auction on behalf of an auction house. When Does a Bid Become Binding? Section 45(3) of the CPA provides that an auction sale is completed when the auctioneer announces its completion by the fall of the hammer or another customary method. Until then, a bidder may retract a bid. All bidders are bound by the Rules of Auction governing their participation in the auction. Once the auction is completed, the successful bidder will also ordinarily be bound by any applicable Conditions of Sale, sale agreement or other agreement governing the purchase. Those agreements may provide for suspensive conditions, such as obtaining finance, regulatory approval, the waiver of pre-emptive rights or third-party consent. A binding agreement may therefore have been concluded even though the transaction cannot yet be implemented. What happens if a suspensive condition is not fulfilled will depend on the agreement concerned. What is a Reserve Price? An auction may be held with or without a reserve price. A reserve price is the minimum price at which the property is intended to be sold. In an ordinary auction, the seller determines or approves the reserve, and the auctioneer may not set one without the seller's express written permission. In a sale in execution, a court may set the reserve. At an auction with reserve, the seller or auctioneer may bid up to the reserve if that right was disclosed in advance. If the reserve is not reached, the seller is not obliged to accept the highest bid, although the seller may agree to a sale below reserve where legally permissible. A court-set reserve cannot simply be disregarded. At an auction without reserve, once bidding starts, the property may not be withdrawn unless no bid is made within a reasonable time. The seller and auctioneer may not bid, or arrange for anyone to bid on the seller's behalf, and the highest bona fide bidder is entitled to the property. Movable Property: When Does Ownership Pass? The fall of the hammer does not necessarily make the successful bidder the owner of movable property. Under common law, ownership generally passes when the parties intend ownership to pass and delivery takes place. In a cash sale, payment is ordinarily also required. Delivery may be physical or take a recognised constructive form, such as handing over the keys to a vehicle or, in appropriate circumstances, where the purchaser already possesses the goods. The sale, payment and transfer of ownership may therefore occur at different times. What About Immovable Property? Different principles apply to immovable property. Although the Alienation of Land Act generally requires agreements for the sale of land to be in writing and signed, section 3(1) expressly excludes sales of land by public auction from those formalities. The Rules of Auction and any Conditions of Sale or sale agreement nevertheless remain important in determining the parties' contractual rights and obligations. As with movable property, a successful bid does not itself transfer ownership. Ownership of immovable property passes only upon registration of transfer in the Deeds Office. Sheriffs' Auctions A sheriff's sale in execution is different from an ordinary voluntary auction. The sheriff sells the property pursuant to court process, usually to satisfy a judgment debt. Section 45 of the CPA expressly includes sales in execution and auctions conducted pursuant to court orders, while the applicable court rules impose additional requirements. Special protection applies to execution against residential immovable property. In such circumstances, the court exercises judicial oversight and must consider, amongst other things, whether execution against a debtor's primary residence is warranted and whether a reserve price should be set. Sheriffs acting in this capacity are also expressly excluded from the relevant definition of a property practitioner under the Property Practitioners Act. Anyone purchasing at a sheriff's auction should carefully consider the Conditions of Sale, particularly the provisions dealing with payment, occupation and transfer. The Rules of Auction Matter The Rules of Auction govern how the auction is conducted, including registration, bidding procedures and reserve-price arrangements. Where the Consumer Protection Regulations apply, written Rules of Auction are required and their contents are prescribed. The auctioneer will also generally have a written agreement with the seller authorising the auction and dealing with matters such as the auctioneer's authority and remuneration. This is often referred to as the Auction Mandate. The contractual provisions governing the eventual sale, such as payment, deposits, delivery or transfer and breach, may form part of the Rules of Auction or be contained in separate Conditions of Sale or a sale agreement. The important point for bidders is to read all the documents governing both the auction and the resulting sale before bidding. What if the Sale Falls Through? The consequences depend on why the transaction failed. If the reserve price is not achieved, there may simply be no sale. If a suspensive condition fails without a breach, the agreement may lapse in accordance with its provisions. If a purchaser defaults after becoming contractually bound, the seller may have remedies including cancellation, damages or specific performance. Depending on the governing agreements and the circumstances of the default, the auctioneer may also have a claim for commission or other agreed charges. A purchaser may likewise have remedies if the seller is in breach. A deposit is not automatically forfeited merely because the transaction does not proceed. Whether it must be refunded, may be retained or may be applied towards a valid claim will depend on why the transaction failed, the governing agreements and the applicable law. Know the Rules Before You Raise Your Hand Auctions are an effective way of selling everything from vehicles and machinery to property and commercial interests, but the fall of the hammer is only part of the legal process. Buyers and sellers should understand who is conducting the auction, when a bid becomes binding, whether a reserve applies, what the Rules of Auction and Conditions of Sale provide, and what happens if the transaction does not proceed. At Le Roux Vivier Attorneys, we assist clients with commercial transactions, property matters, contractual disputes and the preparation and interpretation of auction-related agreements. Before the hammer falls, make sure you know where you stand. Sources: Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 — sections 45 and 55(6). Consumer Protection Regulations, 2011 — regulations 18–30, particularly regulations 21–24 and 28. Property Practitioners Act 22 of 2019 — particularly sections 1 and 48. Alienation of Land Act 68 of 1981 — sections 2 and 3. Uniform Rules of Court — Rules 45, 46 and 46A. Sheriff of the High Court Piketberg and Another v Lourens; In re: Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Trustees for the Time Being of the Eila Trust and Others (3467/2014) [2016] ZAWCHC 93; 2016 (6) SA 110 (WCC). Fraser Stockley BCom Law; LLB Partner at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Novation: When Does A New Agreement Replace An Existing Obligation?
Contracting parties often enter into new agreements to amend existing contractual terms, restructure outstanding debts or resolve disputes. However, the conclusion of a new agreement does not necessarily mean that the previous agreement, or the obligations arising from it, cease to exist. In South African contract law, an important distinction exists between extinguishing an existing obligation and replacing it with a new one, and merely varying the terms of an obligation that continues to exist. This is where the principle of novation becomes relevant. Understanding when novation occurs, and when it does not, can have significant consequences for the rights and obligations of contracting parties, particularly where debts, settlement agreements and acknowledgments of debt are concerned. What is novation? Novation is the replacement of an existing legal obligation with a new obligation, with the result that the original obligation is extinguished. Once a valid novation takes effect, the original obligation can no longer be enforced. For example, two businesses may conclude an agreement for the supply of goods and later agree to abandon that agreement and enter into a new agreement containing different obligations, expressly providing that the new agreement replaces the original agreement. Provided the requirements for a valid contract are satisfied, this would constitute novation. Importantly, however, the mere conclusion of a subsequent agreement does not mean the original agreement, or the obligations arising from it, automatically fall away. Whether novation has occurred depends on whether the parties intended the new agreement to replace, rather than merely amend or supplement, the existing obligation. When does novation occur? In Swadif (Pty) Ltd v Dyke 1978 (1) SA 928 (A), the Appellate Division explained that voluntary novation is fundamentally a matter of intention and agreement. The parties must intend that the existing obligation be extinguished and replaced by a new, valid obligation. South African law recognises a presumption against novation. This means that, where parties enter into a subsequent agreement relating to an existing obligation, the law does not automatically presume that they intended to extinguish the original obligation. Rather, the party alleging novation must establish that the parties intended for the new agreement to replace the existing obligation. This intention, commonly referred to as animus novandi, may be expressed directly in the agreement or inferred from the surrounding circumstances. Where it is not expressly stated, the circumstances must support a clear and necessary inference that the parties intended novation. Novation may therefore occur in circumstances such as the following: 1. Replacement of an existing agreement Parties may expressly agree that a new agreement replaces and supersedes an earlier agreement. For example, a new agreement may provide that all rights and obligations arising from a previous agreement are extinguished and replaced by those contained in the new agreement. Such wording provides strong evidence of an intention to novate, although the agreement must still be interpreted in its proper context. 2. Replacement of an existing obligation Even where the parties do not expressly use the word "novation", their agreement and surrounding conduct may demonstrate an intention to replace an existing obligation. Differences between the old and new obligations may be relevant, including changes to the amount owed, payment obligations, interest provisions and security arrangements. However, these differences are not necessarily conclusive. The question remains whether the parties intended to extinguish the existing obligation and replace it with a new one, or merely vary its terms while leaving the existing obligation in place. 3. Compromise of a disputed claim Novation may also arise through a compromise, known in law as transactio. A compromise occurs where parties settle an existing dispute or uncertainty through an agreement intended to resolve the disputed obligations. Unlike an ordinary repayment arrangement, a genuine compromise may extinguish the original disputed claim and replace it with obligations arising from the settlement. For example, suppose a contractor claims R300 000 for services rendered, but the client disputes the quality of the work and denies liability for the full amount. The parties subsequently agree to settle the dispute through a payment of R200 000 in full and final settlement of the claim, intending that the settlement replace their disputed obligations. Such an agreement may constitute a compromise which, depending on its terms and the parties’ intention, may have the effect of novating the original disputed obligation. The significance of a compromise is that the parties' rights and obligations in respect of the settled dispute are thereafter governed by the compromise agreement. When does novation not occur? Not every subsequent agreement constitutes novation. In many instances, parties intend to preserve an existing obligation while changing how it must be performed or enforced. 1. Acknowledgments of debt An acknowledgment of debt (AOD) is a written document in which a debtor acknowledges an existing indebtedness to a creditor. It may record the amount owed, repayment terms, interest and the consequences of default. An AOD does not automatically novate the underlying debt. For example, suppose a debtor owes a creditor R100 000 under an existing loan agreement. After failing to make payment, the debtor signs an AOD confirming the outstanding amount and undertaking to repay it in monthly instalments. In these circumstances, the AOD may simply confirm the existing liability and regulate its repayment. The original debt has not necessarily been extinguished or replaced. Where an AOD does not constitute novation, the original cause of action may remain available to the creditor, subject to the provisions of the AOD. The creditor cannot, however, recover the same debt twice. Importantly, an AOD can constitute novation where its terms and the parties' intentions establish that the existing obligation was intended to be extinguished and replaced. The distinction therefore does not depend on whether the document is called an AOD, but on its substance and legal effect. 2. Payment arrangements and extensions of time An agreement allowing a debtor additional time to pay, or providing for repayment in instalments, does not ordinarily constitute novation merely because the payment terms have changed. This distinction was illustrated in Shackleton Credit Management CC v Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd and Others 2023 JDR 0996 (GP). The parties had concluded a settlement agreement providing for repayment of an outstanding debt in monthly instalments. One of the questions before the Court was whether the settlement agreement constituted novation. The Court found that the party alleging novation had failed to establish the necessary intention. The agreement had not extinguished the original indebtedness but had instead provided for its repayment and enforcement. Accordingly, the mere restructuring of a debt, even by way of a settlement agreement, does not necessarily result in novation. 3. Amendments to existing agreements Parties may amend certain contractual terms without replacing the underlying agreement. For example, a landlord and tenant may agree to reduce the monthly rental payable under an existing lease agreement while leaving all other terms unchanged. In such circumstances, the original lease agreement continues to operate, subject to the agreed amendment. This constitutes a variation of the existing agreement rather than novation. The distinction is important: variation modifies an existing contractual obligation, whereas novation replaces it. 4. Agreements that supplement existing obligations A subsequent agreement may also introduce additional obligations or mechanisms without extinguishing the original agreement. In Richard Meaden & Associates Incorporated v Global Merchant Supply Services (Pty) Ltd 2025 JDR 4405 (GJ), the Court considered a payment plan and a subsequent payment accommodation. The later document expressly recorded that the earlier payment arrangement remained in full force and effect. The Court rejected the contention that the later arrangement had novated the earlier payment plan. This illustrates the importance of wording that preserves existing obligations. Where parties expressly agree that an earlier agreement remains operative, this may provide compelling evidence against an intention to novate. Why does the distinction matter? Whether an agreement constitutes novation can have important legal and commercial consequences. Firstly, novation affects the enforceability of existing rights. Where an obligation has been validly novated, the creditor generally cannot disregard the replacement agreement and enforce the extinguished obligation. Secondly, novation may affect rights and protections associated with the original obligation, including security arrangements. Parties should therefore consider the effect of novation on existing guarantees, suretyships and other security rights, and whether these are intended to continue in respect of the replacement obligation. Thirdly, the distinction may influence the basis upon which a creditor institutes legal proceedings. Where no novation has occurred, the original cause of action may remain available, whereas a valid novation ordinarily requires enforcement of the replacement obligation. Conclusion The conclusion of a new agreement does not necessarily bring an existing obligation to an end. Whether novation occurs depends on the intention of the parties, the wording of the agreements and the circumstances surrounding their conclusion. An acknowledgment of debt, payment arrangement or contractual amendment may preserve an existing obligation rather than replace it. Conversely, a replacement agreement or compromise may extinguish the original obligation and establish new rights and duties. Before concluding any subsequent agreement, parties should therefore carefully consider its intended legal effect. Zinhle Skosana LLB Candidate Attorney at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Debt Review
Are you struggling to pay your monthly instalments or worried about meeting your essential living expenses? You are not alone. The FinScope Consumer South Africa 2024 survey, released by FinMark Trust in 2025, estimated that approximately 12 million South African adults were experiencing over-indebtedness or financial distress. In terms of the National Credit Act 34 of 2005 (“the Act”), a consumer is over-indebted where the available information indicates that the consumer is, or will be, unable to satisfy all of their obligations under their credit agreements in a timely manner, having regard to their financial means, prospects and obligations, as well as their history of debt repayment. The Act provides mechanisms to assist consumers experiencing financial distress, including debt review. In terms of section 86 of the Act, a consumer may apply to a registered debt counsellor to be declared over-indebted and, where appropriate, for their obligations under credit agreements to be rearranged. The Debt Review Process At Le Roux Vivier Attorneys, we assist clients with the legal aspects of the debt-review process, including liaising with registered debt counsellors, assisting with the necessary court applications and advising clients on the steps required to obtain a clearance certificate and have their debt-review status removed where the applicable statutory requirements have been met. The process generally involves the following steps: Applying for debt review: An application for debt review is made to a debt counsellor registered with the National Credit Regulator. The application is made in the prescribed manner and requires the consumer to provide details of their income, expenses, debts and other financial circumstances. Notification of credit providers and credit bureaux: The debt counsellor will notify your credit providers and the registered credit bureaux of your application for debt review. While the restrictions imposed by the Act remain in effect, you generally may not enter into any further credit agreement, other than a consolidation agreement permitted by the Act. It is important to seek assistance as early as possible. A debt counsellor may not make an application for debt review in respect of a particular credit agreement if the credit provider has already proceeded to take the steps contemplated in section 130 of the Act to enforce that agreement. Assessment of your financial circumstances: The debt counsellor will obtain and verify information regarding your credit obligations and assess your financial circumstances to determine whether you appear to be over-indebted. This assessment takes into account your income, expenses, existing credit obligations and ability to meet those obligations. Proposal to rearrange your obligations: If the debt counsellor reasonably concludes that you are over-indebted, the debt counsellor may issue a proposal recommending that the Magistrates’ Court make an order rearranging one or more of your obligations under your credit agreements. The Act permits a consumer’s obligations to be rearranged by: extending the period of the credit agreement and reducing the amount of each payment accordingly; postponing, for a specified period, the dates on which payments are due; extending the period of the credit agreement and postponing, for a specified period, the dates on which payments are due; or recalculating the consumer’s obligations where this is required as a result of specified contraventions of the Act. The appropriate arrangement will depend on the consumer’s circumstances and the credit agreements involved. Court application: Where appropriate, we will assist with the application to the Magistrates’ Court for the proposed rearrangement of your obligations to be considered. The court will consider the debt counsellor’s proposal and the relevant financial information and may reject the proposal or make an appropriate order contemplated in the Act. Once a rearrangement order has been granted, the consumer must comply with the repayment obligations imposed by that order. Completing debt review and obtaining a clearance certificate: Debt review is not necessarily permanent. Once the requirements of section 71 of the Act have been satisfied, the debt counsellor must issue a clearance certificate. This may occur once all obligations under the credit agreements subject to the debt rearrangement have been satisfied or, in certain circumstances, where all other relevant debts have been settled and the consumer is able to continue meeting the future obligations under a qualifying mortgage agreement without arrears. Once a clearance certificate has been issued, the relevant credit bureaux are required to expunge the prescribed debt-review information from their records in accordance with the Act. If a debt counsellor rejects your application on the basis that you are not over-indebted, you may, with leave of the Magistrates’ Court, apply directly to that court for an order contemplated in section 86(7)(c) of the Act. How We Can Assist Debt review can provide important relief to consumers who are genuinely over-indebted, but the process has significant legal and financial consequences. It is therefore important to understand your rights, obligations and available options before and during the process. At Le Roux Vivier Attorneys, we assist consumers with the legal aspects of debt review, including court applications, disputes arising during the debt-review process and advice regarding the completion of debt review and clearance of debt-review records. Nomalanga Langa LLB Candidate Attorney at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Selling Shares, Selling a Business, or Investing in a Company: What You Should Know
When ownership in a business changes hands, the parties often speak generally about “buying into a business” or “selling the business”. Legally, however, the structure of the transaction matters. There is an important difference between selling shares in a company, selling the business or assets of a company, and investing in a company by subscribing for new shares. Each option has different legal, financial and practical consequences. Understanding the difference is essential before signing any agreement. SELLING SHARES IN A COMPANY A share represents an ownership interest in a company. In terms of section 35(1) of the Companies Act 71 of 2008, a share is movable property and may be transferred in the manner recognised by the Act and the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation. When a shareholder sells shares, the purchaser steps into the seller’s position as shareholder. The company itself usually continues as before. Its contracts, assets, liabilities, employees and operations remain in the company. This means that the purchaser is not simply buying an asset. The purchaser is buying into the company, including its history, risks, liabilities and future potential. A sale of shares is commonly used where: a shareholder wants to exit the company; the remaining shareholders want to buy out a departing shareholder; a purchaser wants to acquire control of a company; business partners want to restructure ownership; an investor wants to acquire an existing shareholder’s stake. Before shares are sold, the parties should review the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation and any shareholders’ agreement. Section 15(1) of the Companies Act recognises the importance of the Memorandum of Incorporation and further provides that shareholders’ agreements must be consistent with the Act and the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation. These documents may contain restrictions on share transfers, pre-emptive rights, valuation mechanisms, board approval requirements, or obligations for a new shareholder to sign a deed of adherence. If these provisions are ignored, the transfer may be delayed or disputed. The parties should also ensure that the company’s securities register is properly updated. Section 50 of the Companies Act requires a company to establish or cause to be established a register of its issued securities, and section 51 deals with the registration and transfer of certificated securities. SELLING THE BUSINESS OR ASSETS A sale of business is different from a sale of shares. In a sale of business, the seller is usually the company itself. The purchaser buys the business, or selected assets of the business, rather than the shares in the company. The assets sold may include stock, equipment, goodwill, intellectual property, customer contracts, vehicles, licences, furniture, lease rights or other business assets. The advantage of this structure is that the purchaser may be able to choose which assets and liabilities it is willing to take over. This can be attractive where the purchaser wants the business opportunity but does not want to assume all historical risks of the company. However, a sale of business may require more practical steps than a sale of shares. Contracts may need to be ceded or assigned, employees may transfer, landlord consent may be required, licences may need to be updated, and customers or suppliers may need to be notified. Where a company disposes of all or the greater part of its assets or undertaking, the Companies Act may require additional approvals. Sections 112 and 115 of the Companies Act regulate certain fundamental transactions and may require shareholder approval by special resolution. This is important because a sale of business is not only a contractual transaction between buyer and seller. In certain circumstances, the Companies Act may require the company to obtain shareholder approval before the transaction can be implemented. INVESTING IN A COMPANY An investment in a company may take a different form altogether. Instead of buying shares from an existing shareholder, an investor may subscribe for new shares issued by the company. In that case, the purchase price is usually paid to the company, not to the existing shareholder. This distinction is important. If an investor buys existing shares, the selling shareholder receives the purchase price and exits fully or partially. If an investor subscribes for new shares, the company receives the funds and may use them for growth, working capital, expansion or other business purposes. Where new shares are issued, sections 38, 39 and 40 of the Companies Act may become relevant. These sections deal with the issuing of shares, pre-emptive rights in respect of certain share issues, and the consideration payable for shares. An investment transaction should clearly regulate: how many shares will be issued; the class of shares; the subscription price; what the investment funds may be used for; voting rights; dividend rights; board representation; reserved matters requiring investor consent; information rights; restrictions on further share issues; exit rights; what happens if performance targets are not met. A new investor should also consider whether the investment will dilute existing shareholders and whether the company’s Memorandum of Incorporation and shareholders’ agreement properly reflect the agreed investment terms. Whether a party is buying shares, buying a business, or investing in a company, due diligence is essential. Due diligence allows the purchaser or investor to understand what they are acquiring and what risks may exist. The documents required will depend on the structure of the transaction. A sale of shares will usually require a sale of shares agreement, share transfer forms, board resolutions, updated securities register entries, and possibly a deed of adherence to a shareholders’ agreement. A sale of business will usually require a sale of business agreement, asset schedules, cession and assignment documents, employee-transfer considerations, landlord consent, supplier or customer consents, and possibly regulatory approvals. An investment transaction may require a subscription agreement, shareholders’ agreement, amended Memorandum of Incorporation, board and shareholder resolutions, and updated company records. In all three cases, the transaction documents should clearly deal with the purchase price, payment terms, suspensive conditions, warranties, indemnities, breach, dispute resolution and closing deliverables. Warranties and indemnities are critical in share sales, business sales and investment transactions. A warranty is a promise about a particular fact. For example, a seller may warrant that the shares are owned by the seller, that the financial information is accurate, or that there is no undisclosed litigation. An indemnity is a specific undertaking to cover a particular risk. For example, if there is a known tax dispute, pending claim or historical liability, the purchaser may require an indemnity if that risk materialises after the transaction. These clauses determine who carries the risk after signature and should be drafted carefully. PRACTICAL QUESTIONS BEFORE SIGNING Before signing, the parties should ask: Are we selling shares, selling the business, or issuing new shares to an investor? Who receives the purchase price: the shareholder or the company? What exactly is being sold? Are the company’s MOI and shareholders’ agreement aligned with the transaction? Are there pre-emptive rights or approval requirements? Has due diligence been completed? Are there existing liabilities, disputes or tax risks? Are contracts, leases, licences or employees affected? Are shareholder or board approvals required? Is Securities Transfer Tax payable? Are warranties and indemnities properly drafted? Have the company records been updated? CONCLUSION A sale of shares, a sale of business and an investment into a company may all appear similar commercially, but they are legally different transactions. The correct structure depends on what the parties want to achieve: an exit, an acquisition, a restructure, or funding for growth. Before signing, parties should understand what is being sold, who is being paid, what liabilities are being assumed, and what approvals are required. The Companies Act should also be considered when structuring the transaction, particularly where shares are transferred, new shares are issued, company records must be updated, or the company disposes of all or the greater part of its assets or undertaking. At Le Roux Vivier Attorneys, we assist shareholders, investors, companies and purchasers with sale of shares agreements, sale of business agreements, subscription agreements, due diligence investigations, shareholders’ agreements, corporate restructuring and commercial advisory services. Ezekiel Dikio LLB Associate at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Why Your Company Should Consider a Custom Memorandum of Incorporation
What is a Memorandum of Incorporation? A Memorandum of Incorporation (“MOI”) is the constitutional document of a company. It regulates important aspects of the relationship between the company, its shareholders and its directors, as well as how the company is governed. In simple terms, it is the company’s internal rulebook or constitution. The importance of the MOI is recognised in section 15 of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 (“the Act”), which permits an MOI, within the limits prescribed by the Act, to regulate and customise various aspects of the company's governance. The MOI is binding between the company and its shareholders, among the shareholders themselves, and between the company and its directors, prescribed officers and board committee members when exercising their functions. Importantly, a shareholders’ agreement must be consistent with both the Act and the company’s MOI. To the extent that a provision of a shareholders’ agreement is inconsistent with the Act or the MOI, that provision is void. For this reason, a company’s MOI and shareholders’ agreement should be drafted and reviewed together to ensure that they are properly aligned. Standard MOI vs custom MOI When a private company is registered, it is often incorporated using a standard-form MOI. This is usually convenient, quick and cost-effective, particularly for simple company structures. However, a standard MOI may not properly deal with the specific needs of the business. A custom MOI is tailored to suit the company’s particular structure, commercial arrangements and long-term plans. It allows shareholders and directors to regulate important issues before disputes arise. This is especially useful where: the company has more than one shareholder; investors are involved; shareholders have different roles or contributions; certain decisions should require special approval; shares may need to be transferred or restricted; the company is family-owned; the company owns valuable assets; the business may be sold in future; and there is a shareholders’ agreement that must be aligned with the MOI. Why a custom MOI matters A custom MOI can create certainty and reduce the risk of disputes. Without proper governance provisions, shareholders and directors may later disagree about who has authority to make decisions, how shares may be transferred, whether new shares may be issued, or what approval is required for major transactions. A well-drafted MOI can regulate matters such as: the powers of directors; the appointment and removal of directors; shareholder voting rights; reserved matters and enhanced approval requirements; issuing new shares; restrictions on share transfers; different classes of shares and the rights attaching to them; pre-emptive rights; meeting procedures; quorum requirements; board authority; deadlock and dispute-resolution mechanisms; and alignment with shareholders’ agreements. These issues may appear technical, but they can become very important when the company grows, brings in investors, issues new shares, acquires valuable assets, undergoes a change in ownership or faces a shareholder dispute. Conclusion A company’s MOI should not be treated as merely an incorporation document filed with CIPC and then forgotten. It is the company's constitutional framework and can have significant legal and commercial consequences throughout the life of the business. A standard MOI may be sufficient for some companies, but businesses with multiple shareholders, investors, valuable assets, or specific governance needs should consider whether a custom MOI is more appropriate. A properly drafted MOI can protect the company, regulate decision-making, align with shareholders’ agreements, and reduce the risk of costly disputes. At Le Roux Vivier Attorneys, we assist companies, directors, shareholders and investors with drafting, reviewing and amending Memoranda of Incorporation, shareholders’ agreements, corporate governance documents and commercial agreements. Ezekiel Dikio LLB Associate at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Suspensive Conditions: Small Clauses With Major Consequences
Agreements often make implementation dependent on something happening first. A purchaser may need to obtain finance, a board or shareholder may need to approve the transaction, or a third party may need to provide written consent. These provisions are generally described as suspensive conditions (and are also often called conditions precedent). They can determine whether a transaction proceeds at all. Careful drafting and a proper understanding of their effect are therefore essential. What is a suspensive condition? A true suspensive condition makes the operation of all or part of an agreement dependent upon the occurrence of a future uncertain event. Until that event occurs, the obligations that depend upon it are suspended. If the condition is fulfilled in the manner and within the period required by the agreement, those obligations become operative. A familiar example is an agreement for the sale of immovable property made subject to the purchaser obtaining mortgage finance by a specified date. The parties have entered into a contractual relationship, but the obligations dependent on the finance condition remain suspended until it is fulfilled or, where permissible, waived. The expressions “suspensive condition” and “condition precedent” are frequently used interchangeably in South African law. In this article, “suspensive condition” is used for both. The word “condition” is also used more broadly in contracts to describe an important or material contractual term. A material term is not necessarily a true suspensive condition: a term ordinarily imposes an obligation capable of performance and breach, whereas a true condition makes the operation of the contract, or part of it, dependent upon an uncertain event. The correct classification therefore depends on the substance and effect of the clause, not simply on whether the drafter has labelled it a “condition”, “condition precedent” or “suspensive condition”. What is a resolutive condition? A resolutive condition operates in the opposite direction. The agreement, or the relevant obligations, operates immediately but comes to an end if a specified future uncertain event occurs. For example, a lease might provide that it takes effect immediately but will terminate if a specified operating licence is finally refused. The tenant may occupy and trade while the application is pending; if the licence is refused, the resolutive condition is triggered, and the lease terminates in accordance with its terms. Under a suspensive condition, performance is held back pending the event whereas under a resolutive condition, the agreement operates until the event occurs. Why are suspensive conditions important? Their function is best illustrated by a practical example. Assume that shares in a company operating a franchised business are sold to a third party, but the franchise agreement requires the franchisor’s prior written consent to a change of control. If the share sale simply requires transfer on a fixed date, without making the franchisor’s consent a suspensive condition, implementation could place the company in breach of the franchise agreement or materially undermine the value of the business being acquired. If the consent is made a suspensive condition, the parties can conclude the agreement while making implementation dependent on that consent. If consent is obtained, the transaction proceeds. If it is refused and the condition cannot be waived, the transaction does not proceed. Suspensive conditions therefore allocate risk by allowing parties to commit to a transaction without requiring implementation before essential legal, regulatory, financial or commercial prerequisites have been satisfied. Common examples The appropriate conditions will depend on the transaction. Common examples include: a purchaser obtaining finance or a mortgage bond; board or shareholder approval of a transaction; regulatory, competition or governmental approval; consent from a franchisor, landlord, lender, supplier or other contracting party where a transaction or change of control requires consent; compliance with rights of first refusal or pre-emptive rights; completion of a due diligence investigation; the incorporation of a company and, where relevant, the adoption or ratification of a pre-incorporation arrangement; completion of another interdependent transaction; and the passing of resolutions and satisfaction of statutory requirements under the Companies Act 71 of 2008. Statutory approvals or corporate resolutions may also be genuine prerequisites to implementation. Where the law requires a particular approval or resolution before a transaction may be implemented, the agreement should identify that requirement clearly and deal expressly with the consequences if it is not obtained. What happens while the condition is outstanding? It is sometimes said that there is “no contract” until a suspensive condition is fulfilled. That is too simplistic. In Mia v Verimark Holdings (Pty) Ltd, the Supreme Court of Appeal described the conclusion of a contract subject to a suspensive condition as creating a “very real and definite contractual relationship” between the parties, while the exigible content dependent on the condition remains suspended. The formulation has also been applied in later cases. This matters in practice. Provisions intended to operate from signature may already bind the parties, such as confidentiality obligations, duties to cooperate in procuring fulfilment, dispute-resolution provisions, and the provisions governing the condition itself. A well-drafted agreement should therefore identify which provisions apply immediately and which obligations become operative only once the condition has been fulfilled or validly waived. What happens if the condition is fulfilled? If a suspensive condition is fulfilled within the stipulated period, the suspended obligations become operative in accordance with the agreement. In Africast (Pty) Ltd v Pangbourne Properties Ltd, the Court explained that a contract containing a suspensive condition is enforceable upon conclusion although some obligations are postponed pending fulfilment. Once fulfilled, the contract and mutual rights are treated as operating with the legal effect attributed to fulfilment. Remo Ventures Pty Ltd v Cecile Van Zyl and Others later restated these principles. For drafting purposes, it is often useful to define an “Effective Date” by reference to the date on which the last suspensive condition is fulfilled or validly waived. Payment periods, closing obligations and other implementation timelines can then run from a clearly identifiable date rather than from signature. What happens if the condition is not fulfilled? If a suspensive condition is not fulfilled within the stipulated period, and is neither validly waived nor extended in time, the obligations dependent upon it fall away. If the condition suspends the whole transaction, the agreement ordinarily lapses in accordance with its terms and the applicable law. Africast illustrates the importance of the deadline: the agreement lapsed because the stipulated condition was not fulfilled timeously. More recently, in Maria Luisa Palma Codevilla v Kennedy-Smith NO, the Court confirmed that once an agreement has lapsed for non-fulfilment of a suspensive condition there is nothing left to “revive”. A later waiver or purported extension cannot resurrect the lapsed agreement. If the parties still wish to transact, they must conclude a new agreement, which may of course adopt the same commercial terms but must deal afresh with the failed condition and comply with any applicable formalities. A deadline for fulfilment is therefore not merely administrative. If the parties need more time, any extension should be agreed before the deadline expires and in the manner required by the agreement. The agreement should also regulate what happens to deposits, documents, possession, confidential information and any performance already rendered, and identify the provisions intended to survive a lapse. Fictional fulfilment: a party cannot necessarily engineer failure A party may not always be entitled to rely on non-fulfilment where it deliberately caused the condition to fail. South African law recognises the doctrine of fictional fulfilment. Broadly, where the party against whom the condition operates deliberately prevents its fulfilment with the required intention of frustrating the obligation, the law may in appropriate circumstances treat the condition as fulfilled against that party. The doctrine is not automatic. Intention and causation must be established, and fictional fulfilment may be inappropriate where the outcome depends on an independent public or third-party discretion. For example, suppose a sale is subject to municipal approval of a land-use application, and the seller is obliged to take reasonable steps to pursue it. A deliberate failure by the seller to submit documents within its control may raise questions about prevention of fulfilment, but the court cannot simply deem the municipality’s independent approval to have been granted where the statutory decision requires the municipality to consider the public interest and third-party rights. Hanuscke v Kungwini Local Municipality illustrates this distinction: the outstanding conditions depended on a public process involving interests beyond the contracting parties, and there was no room on those facts for fictional fulfilment. When may a suspensive condition be waived? The starting point is to determine for whose benefit the condition was inserted. If a condition is inserted exclusively for the benefit of one party, that party may generally waive it, provided the condition is legally capable of waiver and the agreement does not provide otherwise. A common example is a finance condition inserted solely for the purchaser’s protection: a purchaser who can fund the purchase independently may, in principle, elect not to insist on the specified finance. If the condition benefits both parties, one party cannot ordinarily dispense with it unilaterally. Nor can a mandatory statutory requirement, or a consent that the law or a third-party contract actually requires, simply be wished away by describing it as waived. Timing is critical. A waiver must ordinarily occur before the deadline for fulfilment. Once the agreement has lapsed, there is no subsisting agreement or right to waive. If the parties still wish to proceed, a new agreement is required. Even if the agreement is silent on waiver, a condition inserted solely for one party’s benefit may in principle be waivable. The safer course is to state expressly which conditions may be waived, by whom, by when and in what form. How should suspensive conditions be drafted? A good suspensive-condition clause should do more than say that an agreement is “subject to” something happening. It should address the mechanics of the condition with precision. In particular, the agreement should identify: the event or approval required for fulfilment; whether the condition suspends the whole agreement or only specified obligations; the party responsible for taking the necessary steps; whether that party must use reasonable endeavours, best endeavours or some other defined standard; the deadline for fulfilment; what evidence will demonstrate fulfilment; for whose benefit the condition is inserted; whether the condition may be waived and, if so, by whom; the form and deadline for any waiver; how and when the fulfilment date may be extended; the consequences of non-fulfilment; and which provisions remain binding while the condition is pending and after lapse. The event should also be stated objectively wherever possible. Expressions such as “subject to satisfactory arrangements” or “subject to approval” can create disputes if the agreement does not identify whose satisfaction or approval is required, the standard to be applied, and the time within which the decision must be made. The practical lesson Suspensive conditions are often short clauses with consequences far greater than their length suggests. Poor drafting can leave parties uncertain about whether an agreement is operative, whether an approval was obtained in time, whether a condition can be waived and whether the transaction has lapsed. The safest approach is to identify genuine prerequisites to implementation at the drafting stage and regulate fulfilment, waiver, extension, non-fulfilment and survival expressly. The important question is not the label attached to the clause, but what it actually does and what the parties intend to happen if the uncertain event does, or does not, occur. This article is intended as general information on South African contract law and does not constitute legal advice. The legal effect of any condition depends on the wording, context and applicable statutory framework of the particular agreement. Fraser Stockley BCom Law; LLB Partner at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.
- Regulation of Trusts Bill, 2026: What Trustees and Beneficiaries Need to Know
South Africa’s law governing trusts may soon undergo its most significant overhaul in decades. The Regulation of Trusts Bill, 2026 (“the Bill”) proposes to repeal and replace the Trust Property Control Act 57 of 1988, introducing a considerably more detailed regulatory framework for the creation, administration and oversight of trusts. Cabinet approved the Bill for publication for public comment on 29 July 2026, describing its objectives as modernising the law of trusts, strengthening accountability and compliance, enhancing the oversight role of the Master of the High Court, and providing greater protection to beneficiaries. Importantly, the Bill is not yet law. It was published for public comment on 7 August 2026, and interested parties currently have until Friday, 11 September 2026 to submit written comments to the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development. There is therefore no fixed date on which the proposed changes will take effect. The Bill must still proceed through the legislative process and may be amended before it is enacted. As presently drafted, the eventual Regulation of Trusts Act will come into operation on a date determined by the President by proclamation in the Government Gazette. Why is the law changing? The present Trust Property Control Act was enacted in 1988 and has not undergone a comprehensive review during the intervening decades. According to the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development, the Bill is intended, amongst other things, to address weaknesses in the existing framework relating to trustee accountability, the Master's ability to exercise effective oversight, the protection of beneficiaries and transparency regarding the control of trust property. It is also intended to better align South Africa's trust regime with Financial Action Task Force (“FATF”) requirements concerning money laundering and related financial crime risks. The Bill seeks to consolidate and strengthen an already increasingly compliance-driven trust regulatory environment, while introducing additional reporting, enforcement and oversight mechanisms. What are the most important proposed changes? More formal requirements for creating a valid trust: The Bill expressly provides that a trust is created where the founder, clearly and with reasonable certainty, indicates an intention to create a trust, identifies the trust property, identifies the beneficiaries or classes of beneficiaries (or the object of the trust), and appoints a trustee or provides for the appointment of one. The object must be lawful, and a sole trustee may not simultaneously be the sole beneficiary. A court may declare a trust invalid where these requirements are not satisfied. The Bill places these requirements expressly on a statutory footing and provides specific consequences where they are not met. Greater powers for the Master of the High Court: The Bill retains and expands the Master's supervisory role. The Master already has powers under the existing framework to require trustees to account and to produce records and documents, but the Bill introduces a more detailed statutory framework governing oversight, investigations, compliance and enforcement. The Bill also regulates the appointment of additional trustees in greater detail. In particular, where all trustees are beneficiaries, all trustees are related to one another, and the trust conducts business or trading activities with third parties, the Master may appoint an independent trustee where this is considered necessary to ensure the separation of control and enjoyment of trust property. The effectiveness of these expanded powers will, however, depend substantially on the administrative capacity of the Master's Offices. Additional regulatory responsibilities may improve oversight in principle, but without corresponding improvements in systems, staffing and turnaround times there is a risk that the Bill increases the compliance burden on trustees without producing an equivalent improvement in administration or enforcement. Trustee authorisation and disqualification: The Bill retains the existing principle that a trustee may not act without written authorisation from the Master, while setting out a more detailed statutory framework governing trustee authorisation and disqualification. It identifies categories of persons who may be disqualified from acting as trustees and continues the framework for a public register of persons disqualified from being authorised to act as trustees. Annual financial statements and annual returns: One of the Bill's more significant practical changes is the formalisation of financial reporting under trust legislation itself and the introduction of an annual return to the Master. The Bill expressly requires trustees to cause annual financial statements to be prepared, subject to an exemption where the trust falls below thresholds to be determined by the Minister and the trust instrument does not itself require financial statements. Although the present Trust Property Control Act does not impose an equivalent general statutory obligation, many trusts already prepare annual financial statements or annual administration accounts in order to comply with their trust deeds, accounting requirements and SARS obligations. In addition, trustees will be required to file a prescribed annual return with the Master and pay the prescribed fee. This return is separate from the trust's existing annual income-tax return to SARS and will therefore constitute an additional regulatory filing. Existing trusts will be required to file their first annual return within six months after commencement of the Act. Further formalisation of beneficial ownership requirements: Beneficial-ownership disclosure is not new. Trustees are already required to establish, record and lodge beneficial-ownership information with the Master. The Bill retains these obligations, adopts a broad definition of “beneficial owner” and requires changes to be recorded and lodged within 10 days. More detailed statutory record-keeping requirements: The Bill sets trustees' existing record-keeping duties out in greater detail and requires specified records to be retained throughout the trusteeship and for five years thereafter. These include the trust instrument and amendments, financial and accounting records, trustee resolutions, contracts and records relating to trust property and the appointment or removal of trustees. Clear separation of trust property: The Bill retains and restates the existing principle that trust property must be kept separate from a trustee's personal estate and must be clearly identified as trust property. It also continues the requirement that money received in a trustee's capacity as trustee be held in a separate account in the name of the trust. The Bill also provides a more detailed statutory framework for trustee investment decisions, including a prudent-investor standard and prescribed considerations relevant to investment decisions. It also consolidates existing requirements relating to dealings with accountable institutions. Compliance notices and personal administrative fines: One of the clearest practical changes introduced by the Bill is its structured administrative enforcement regime. The Master may issue a compliance notice where a trustee fails, amongst other things, to provide required contact details, account to the Master, submit requested financial statements, file an annual return or comply with beneficial-ownership requirements. Failure to remedy the non-compliance may then result in an administrative fine. This creates a distinct compliance-notice and administrative-fine mechanism within the new statutory framework. Crucially, an administrative fine imposed on a trustee must be paid personally by that trustee and may not be recovered from trust property. Significant criminal penalties: The Bill also retains severe criminal sanctions for certain contraventions, including fines of up to R10 million and imprisonment for up to five years in specified cases. Similar penalties already exist under the current Act, but the Bill combines criminal sanctions with the new compliance-notice and administrative-fine regime. What does the Bill mean for existing trusts? Existing trustees should review their trust deeds, governance procedures, financial records and beneficial-ownership information in preparation for the proposed annual return, financial-reporting requirements, shorter beneficial-ownership updating periods and new administrative enforcement regime. Will the Bill create additional red tape? Inevitably, yes. The Bill introduces additional filings, prescribed fees, shorter compliance periods and a new administrative enforcement regime. This is particularly significant because trusts already provide substantial information to SARS, the Master's Office and financial institutions. The proposed annual return to the Master therefore raises a legitimate question whether better information-sharing between State institutions could achieve some of the same objectives without duplicating compliance obligations. There is also a question of proportionality. Large trading trusts and comparatively simple family trusts do not necessarily present the same regulatory risks. A more risk-based approach may better balance transparency and accountability against the cost of compliance. Much will still depend on the regulations Certain details of the proposed regime remain to be prescribed by regulation, including the form of annual returns and applicable fees, the thresholds for exemptions from annual financial statements, and the maximum administrative fines. A significant change in the regulation of South African trusts The Bill is best understood as a consolidation and expansion of South Africa's existing trust regulatory framework. While many provisions restate or formalise existing obligations, the annual return to the Master, administrative-fine regime and more prescriptive compliance requirements will create additional obligations. Greater transparency and trustee accountability are legitimate objectives. The real test will be whether the additional regulation results in better governance and enforcement rather than simply more administration — particularly given that the effectiveness of the new regime will depend heavily on the capacity of the Master's Offices. The Bill remains open for public comment until 11 September 2026, and its provisions may still change before becoming law. Le Roux Vivier Attorneys assists individuals, families and businesses with the creation and registration of trusts, the drafting and amendment of trust deeds, trust administration and compliance, estate and succession planning, and trust-related disputes. This article is intended for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The Regulation of Trusts Bill, 2026 remains draft legislation and may be amended during the legislative process. The position stated is current as at 10 September 2026. Fraser Stockley BCom Law; LLB Partner at Le Roux Vivier Attorneys Disclaimer: The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm. This content is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. While every effort is made to ensure accuracy, the law may change and its application depends on the specific facts of each matter. Readers should seek professional legal advice before acting on any information contained herein. The firm and the author(s) accept no liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on this content.











